Anyone read "Disney War", by James B. Stewart?

Deb in IA

Knows that KIDS are better
Joined
Aug 18, 1999
Messages
12,607
I read a review of it in TIME magazine. Sounds interesting. Talks about Eisner's rise and fall in the Walt Disney Corporation, his disastrous decisions and his managerial style, and his relationship with COO Robert Iger. Calls Eisner "Cruella deVil", and seems to really give an insider's view of the inner circles at the Disney Corporation.



The Tragic Kingdom
A scandalous new book on Disney has dirt by the shovelful, roiling the House of Mouse
By JAMES PONIEWOZIK

Monday, Feb. 21, 2005

At the annual disney shareholders' meeting last week in Minneapolis, Minn., the hefty document that attendees were most eager to get their hands on was not an annual report. It was James B. Stewart's DisneyWar (Simon & Schuster; 572 pages), which chronicles how CEO Michael Eisner--who announced last year that he would step down in 2006--turned their pop-culture institution into a Tragic Kingdom.

Bookstores around Minneapolis' Convention Center reportedly did not have it in stock, which was one scrap of good news for Disney president and COO Robert Iger. A leading candidate to replace Eisner, Iger cannot be helped in his bid by his portrayal in DisneyWar as Eisner's beaten cur--a disrespected, whiny No. 2 with poor judgment, serving a CEO who wanted a nonthreatening deputy to "take all the s___" of running a company. And Eisner says more than once that Iger is unfit to take his job. Iger, he says, "can never succeed me."

But say this for Iger: at least he is not Eisner, who is to DisneyWar what Cruella De Vil was to 101 Dalmatians. Amazingly, Stewart--Pulitzer-prizewinning author of the insider-trading exposé Den of Thieves--had the cooperation of Eisner and Disney, having approached them in early 2003 to do a book on how Disney was adapting to the changing media world. Eisner granted him interviews; Stewart even wore a Goofy costume at Walt Disney World. But within a few months he had ringside seats as Roy Disney, nephew of founder Walt Disney, launched a shareholder revolt against the man he blamed for hobbling a thriving entertainment giant.

That there was a thriving giant to hobble owes much to Eisner. Hired in 1984, he brought back the company--moribund and churning out flops like Tron--by turning out hit movies like Pretty Woman and Beauty and the Beast. The story gets good when things go bad, beginning in the early 1990s, as Disney falls to intracorporate civil war and Eisner's golden gut turns to lead. (Treasure Planet, anyone?)

The major events in DisneyWar are familiar: Eisner's fallings-out with lieutenants Jeffrey Katzenberg and Michael Ovitz, the turbulence at the acquired ABC network. But Stewart gleans fantastic fly-on-the-wall reportage from his inside access, interviews and Eisner's revealing notes and e-mails. Some of these incidents put Iger in a bad light just as the Disney board is considering CEO candidates. At the end of an argument between him and ABC chairman Lloyd Braun, Iger gets so agitated that he accidentally hits a waiter, who spills coffee down Iger's shirt. Not that Iger's own treatment was better. During a rough patch, Ovitz suggests that Eisner give Iger a gift to shore up his confidence. Eisner balks. "Don't you want him to be comfortable, happy in his job?" Ovitz asks. A beat passes. "Not really," Eisner says.

So it goes for hundreds of blistering pages. How do you know that somebody is about to be fired or forced out at Disney? When Eisner professes loyalty to him. How do you know when someone at Disney is about to have a great success? When she gets fired or forced out. Braun, for instance, is booted just before his brainchild Lost--derided by Eisner and Iger--becomes a Top 10 hit.

Stewart's take is that while a successful jerk may be forgiven all, Eisner indulged his vanity and vindictiveness to his company's harm. He cost Disney millions of dollars and vast embarrassment by letting Katzenberg's departure deteriorate into a lawsuit. He even badmouths Lost--his own network's hit--to Stewart, to rationalize having opposed it. ("Lost is terrible," he says. "Who cares about these people on a desert island?")

Last week's shareholder meeting ended quietly, but the nasty succession drama is far from over. Eisner calls the intrigue at Disney "Shakespearean," and Stewart likens the CEO to Lear and Richard III--though the literary comparison undeservedly puffs up DisneyWar and Eisner. A media leader squandering his company's worth, a tyrannical boss, a failure clinging to power--these are dog-bites-man stories that Stewart simply bundles up in a deliciously toxic, if underanalyzed, package. It's not a tragedy worthy of the Bard, but it is a lusty roll in greed and spite. In other words, a good old-fashioned Hollywood production.

http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,1027502,00.html

More about the book on amazon:

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/A...20/sr=2-1/ref=pd_ka_b_2_1/104-3815827-5660732
 
Can't wait to read it. They were talking about it today on my local radio station (who coincidentally is owned by ABC/Disney) and they said it was a fascinating read.
 
I saw him last night on Fox News while just flipping through the channels. I think it was during Bill O'Reily's show, but I'm not sure. I do want to read that book.
 
I am reading it now. I am early in the book but there were a couple of surprises; It seems it was more Card Walker and not Ron Miller that contributed to the stagnation of the company pre Eisner. Roy O and Walt had an early dispute about money, ownership and even the name; changing it from the Disney Brothers Studio to Walt Disney Studio. They didn't speak for a while. Roy E was referred to for years as the "idiot nephew" but so far, if there are any heroes in this story, Roy E has been the only one to want to restore the company to its previous, untainted glory. He is wealthy in his own right so what ever action he is taking now is to preserve the name and the reputation. Also significant is the commentary this morning that James Stewart said the Eisner is a dishonest man, citing several examples of his lies. I got the book last night at Barnes and Nobel.
 

Ron Miller was Walt's son-in-law, right? As in Daisy Disney Miller's husband?

What intrigues me about this book is that 1) Stewart is a reputable writer; he's a Pulitzer winner for his expose about insider trading and 2) Stewart, amazingly, had the cooperation of Eisner and the Disney Corporation when he started this project -- I'll bet Michael E. is really steaming about that now!!!
 
Katie Couric did interviews with Stewart yesterday and today. Very interesting. I definitely will be picking up the book - but not until after our upcoming trip. Gonna pretend all is happy with my Magical Kingdom between now and then.
 
Deb in IA said:
Ron Miller was Walt's son-in-law, right? As in Daisy Disney Miller's husband?

What intrigues me about this book is that 1) Stewart is a reputable writer; he's a Pulitzer winner for his expose about insider trading and 2) Stewart, amazingly, had the cooperation of Eisner and the Disney Corporation when he started this project -- I'll bet Michael E. is really steaming about that now!!!

Diane Disney. What hurt Ron Miller was that he was separated from Diane at the time of the big decision to jettison him. He didn't have the support of the family because of that. I think that they got back together. Stewart did have the cooperation of Eisner but that was when all was percieved to be sunshine and pixie dust in Eisner's world. 9/11 put the book on hold and when he got back to it, Roy E has started the internal war. Additionally, one gets the impression that Eisner thinks that he is the smartest man in the room and constantly underestimates those around him. As a result he attempts to get away with lies, misstatements and thinks he is powerful enough to direct the show (the book) because he granted access. One of the problems is, Stewart didn't just interview Eisner but those who love and hate him as well. He also had access to public court documents, interviews, etc which doesn't paint Eisner in a good light. While Eisner does think he is the smartest guy in the room, part of that seems borne of insecurity. That would explain his resistance to grooming a number two man all of these years. He got along with Wells because Wells was willing to take the number two slot from the get go. There was no competition.
 
I've not read this book but I am a big fan of James B. Stewart. Should be an interesting book.
 
Finished this book last week. I was a very interesting read. I have read Michael Eisners biography, so it was enlighting, (understatement) to read the other half of the story. DawnCT1, you hit it on the head about his insecurity. Shocking for such an outwardly confident man.

It didn't change my opinion of Disney brand any. The degree of detail in all they do is a winner in my book.

I now understand the "Save Disney" efforts and agree with them.

I don't think the Disney executives put enough stock into the theme parks. We as consumers, vacation in this Magic, make believe world, then go home and spend more money to because we enjoyed ourselves so daggone much. The only reason I took a Disney Cruise vs. any other, was solely on my past experiences.

Fasinating book if you like the "behind the scenes" stuff.
 
I have read both this and "Storming The Magic Kingdom". If you have read Disney Wars (and liked it) I would strongly suggest you find Storming the Magic Kingdom. In fact, Stewart quotes from this book extensively in the early chapters.

This book explores Disney through the neer hotstile takeover attempted by Saul Steinberg (which eventually brought Eiser and Frank Wells in to the picture). It gives deep coverage to colorful Disney heros and villans such as: Roy Disney, Stanley Gold, Card Walker, Ron Miller, Sid Bass and Iwrin Jacobs.

Reading Disney Wars you really feel that Orvitz was doomed from the beginning by his own best freind and confidant. In the end I guess the true story is somewhat in the middle. Orvitz was arrogant - but - Eisner did absolutely nothing to give this man any support.

The last year or so I had been thinking that Roy D. and Stan Gold where just as Eisner proclaimed: Dissidents and Crazys. I certainly have much more sympathy and respect for the Save Disney campaign.
 
I have it on my bookshelf. I'm going to try and start it here shortly. Sounds like a good read.
 
Yes, I read it. It was an interesting book. I do wish it had more to do with the parks though.

It was very in depth of how the business end was though.
 
Reading it now......can't put it down..
 





New Posts










Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top