I'll preface this by saying I consider myself a HUGE Star Wars fan. I'm also more "old school" and favor the Original Trilogy, but I'm not opposed to the prequel Trilogy or the more recent 3 (except Force Awakens, while entertaining, is in large part a re-hash of New Hope's plot...). So:
I really, really wanted to like Galaxy's Edge. I just can't get to that point. I LOVE Rise of the Resistance as a ride even with it based on the whiny/non-scary Kylo Ren. Would have been better with Darth Vader. But, still an amazing ride and I'll go on it any chance I get. Falcon is just another simulator/screen ride. Otherwise, there just isn't much to do there. Yes, it is beautiful and so-well built! However, I think they totally missed the boat by sticking to the First Order/Resistance timeframe instead of all of Star Wars. Give me Yoda. Tying the land to a specific point in time was in my opinion a huge mistake. Embrace all of Star Wars. I think Vader, Luke, Leia, Yoda, Han etc would be very popular there. Yeah, I know they are trying to immerse me in the experience. But I don't we all actually know we are at a theme park. You know, people dressed normal everywhere, Mickey Head balloons, etc
When I ask if you accept Disney Visa merchandise discounts, just say "yes" or "no". Don't try to re-word it into some other verbiage back at me. And "bright suns" makes me think to find some shade. Good morning would put a smile on my face.
The other huge miss in my opinion is the lack of Star Wars music. Every other land (I think) has music to draw you in to what you are experiencing. If Baatu had actual Star Wars music playing it would be a huge improvement, at least for me. I'm to the point now when I walk into the land that I just play Star Wars music on my phone.
As for Star Tours and the shop in Tomorrowland, I'm okay with those but Tomorrowland is our least-favorite land since it just doesn't feel Disney. We spend very little time there compared to the other lands.
So, I LOVE Star Wars, I'm IMPRESSED by the construction of Galaxy's Edge, but we basically just go their to ride Rise, take a quick walk-through of the area, then get out. I really wish I could have felt different about it. I really wanted to love the land but it just doesn't have an emotional connection for me, which really surprised me (and shocked my wife).