After posting this almost same question about a month ago and saying I had decided to take my chances and not get
travel insurance, I changed my mind and broke down yesterday and bought it. I had checked on the internet and decided on CSA Travel Protection's Freestyle Plan for $100.54. I had originally looked at insuremy trip.com, who also offeres the same plan with the same company. I decided to call CSA directly to verify what the different plans covered. The agent was very honest and said their $100.54 free style plan really provided more coverage than their $148.00 Siver Plan. She said the Silver Plan was bracketed and covered any trip 3 days-30 days for the same price and alot of people didn't like that they paid the same amount for 3 days that someone else paid for 30 days so they came up with the freestyle plan, which is customized for your length of stay. She did say specifically that it would cover any trip delay of at least 6 hours or more or a cancellation related to a Florida hurricane. She e-mailed me all 25 pages of the policy and it says
Travel Delay must be caused by or result from:
a-d
e. natural disaster or adverse weather
It also says the following is covered:
1. Common Carrier delays resulting from inclement weather, or mechanical breakdown...
2. Arrangements cancelled by an airline, ... or delays of 6 hours or more requiring accomodations, clothing, meals, phone calls...etc.
It lists a bunch of other stuff covered too (including if one of us is summoned for jury duty, loses our job, death in the family, involved in a car wreck during or before the trip, etc, which I thought was interesting).
I decided I wanted the peace of mind of not worrying about losing money due to a hurricane, so it was easily worth the $100.54. When I called Disney yesterday to add our DME info I asked the CM about travel insurance and we talked about Disney being so good last year during the hurricanes about giving people free tickets and comping them back on their rooms. She made the comment that very few hurricanes hit WDW, so Disney doesn't usually have to do everything they did last year and they didn't realize how much it was going to cost them when they did it. She said she could not see them doing it again this year as people coming down there now knew what to expect.

She highly recommended travel insurance for this year.