If you are talking about the "Barefoot, Sail and Snorkel" I can tell you a little. We booked it last year, and were looking forward to it. I had read some GREAT reviews on it and just so happen to meet a women here in Charleston who's granddaughter was one of the co-owners! Small world!
On the night before the Magic got to St Thomas I was called by guest services and told not enough people booked, so it was being cancelled! I was very dissapointed. I thought they did not do a good job with the discribtion of the excursion (I found out myself that beverages are included) and since the price was a few dollars more then the other catamaran trip, this might have made the difference to some people.
I saw "Honeymoon Beach" on the way to Trunk Bay and it looked REALLY nice!
This was my only dissapointment of the whole cruise.
If you do go, please tell us about it when you return.
BTW the granddaughters name is Claire, her DH is Jamie. They own and run the Catamaran "Allura".