We can only manage to make it to WDW during the summers (the curse of working in education). Hence we get two trips out of our AP's. The additional perks that come with AP's don't hurt either. We opt not to renew the AP skipping a year otherwise we don't get as much out of the AP. We are considering switching to the Park Hopper since we've been spending more time at the resorts. It all depends on what you plan to do, how often you visit the WDW within a year, etc.