American Idol Season 9 Thread Top 5

[chisnpeke]

at Ellen.

 

[asta]

Crystal gets extra credit for picking a song from Caddy Shack. I liked this but it wasn't great.

Casey and Mike are doing great. This is the first time I have liked Mike. I think this was the best of the night.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

I used to

 

[StephyDee]

LOL ELLEN "In fact, I have loved a woman."


and Sorry, but they weren't THAT great as Kara is making them to be. Her crush is showing.

 

[Nancy]

Mike said the song was about whales?? for real??? ugh....can people just STOP voting for him??


the DIS is acting up anyway, so i understand.

No, he said the movie was about whales....which technically Free Willie was..but it is about a bit more than just a whale.

 

[Mean Queen]

For Lil - Ellen said after the guys sang "Have You Ever Really Loved A Woman" - Yes, I actually have loved a woman.

 

[charming23]

How could they have liked that? I had to put it on mute. I love that song and would like to continue loving it.

 

[Cat0727]

Big Mike did NOT try to sing "Will You Be There!" What a dope!

 

[Nancy]

Glee time! I love that show

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

LOL ELLEN "In fact, I have loved a woman."


and Sorry, but they weren't THAT great as Kara is making them to be. Her crush is showing.

For Lil - Ellen said after the guys sang "Have You Ever Really Loved A Woman" - Yes, I actually have loved a woman.

No, he said the movie was about whales....which technically Free Willie was..but it is about a bit more than just a whale.

obviously it was about much more than whales. i can't believe he keeps saying stuff like that...

 

[DarthKTrava]

Mike said the song was about whales?? for real??? ugh....can people just STOP voting for him??


the DIS is acting up anyway, so i understand.

Something was making the computer crash. Dunno if something crapped on Firefox... Right now I'm using IE.

 

[charming23]

Glee time! I love that show

Me too and they have people who can actually sing

 

[Robinrs]

Is this year OVER yet?

 

[DarthKTrava]

I wasn't wowed by it. The duets were better then the solo songs.

ITA And so does Simon. Too bad one can't vote based on those.....

 

[DarthKTrava]

Too funny Ellen!

And it was the truth, too.....

 

[Cat0727]

For Lil - Ellen said after the guys sang "Have You Ever Really Loved A Woman" - Yes, I actually have loved a woman.

Funniest thing she's said all season!

 

[DarthKTrava]

No, he said the movie was about whales....which technically Free Willie was..but it is about a bit more than just a whale.

One can also say that Star Trek IV was about whales too....

 

[StephyDee]

Okay, here's my thoughts for the night:

Lee - he's still one of my favorites, but this wasn't his best performance (the solo one)....could've done worse though, so not a total loss.

Mike - go. home. now. please. The singing was okay, but his attitude is just making me SO agitated.

Casey - his rendition isn' t that bad. I used to listen to this song as a kid (again, my parents' fault lol), and he didn't butcher it. Not the best of choices though, when it comes to subject matter, seeing the obvious situation with him and Kara.

Crystal - Her singing was alright, but.....she's just not clicking for me anymore. I see her flaws more and more in her singing, since all her songs sound the same, and it's getting me annoyed. Not at HER, per se, but at the fact that she isn't switching it up enough for me.


DUETS:

Lee and Crystal: LOVED this version. It got loads better towards the chorus, and I still find it freaky that we all here talked about last year's rendition of the song as they go to sing the song right then and there....without the help of song spoilers.

Casey and Mike: Meh.....it's was like 5/10...it sounded alright, but Mike was overpowering Casey a tiny bit, and it wasn't all 'there'. Seemed a teensy bit awkward. Ask me why and I won't tell you...because IDK.


I want Casey or Mike to go. Please. Mike moreso than Casey.

 

[LiLIrishChick63]

One can also say that Star Trek IV was about whales too....

 

[GaRain]

Long time watcher, first time caller...

ok, poster.....

Huge AI fan, just found this thread and thought I would join in - just a little late.
Really, the only thing I can see is a Lee and Crystal finale!!
But this has been a pretty boring season....


Lara