American Idol Season 12 Official Thread

[mandy200587]

I should've known!!



Boy did i love BO back in his season!! Is he still dealing with gastro issues? My ex had them, it's so hard to live with.

I hate the amber love fest and I want Kree top 3 and I'll be okay.

I don't know, I've not heard a ton about him lately. He's in a film about the flood we had almost 3 years ago

 

[mandy200587]

I'm watching Idol commentary with two musical professionals from town. One of them said she was try to be the diva instead of being Amber. Agreed this wasn't Candice's best week. Think Kree is in danger but she'll be talking to the station here locally soon. Said Angie was the best of the night.

 

[mandy200587]

So late night not ready to sleep I am on youtube looking at Kree videos and I found this....same song she did tonight during Free Choice but in my opinion much better. I think a band makes a huge bit of difference

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Khi89iKMSKI

 

[TruBlu]

Finally! I actually watched the show on the night it was on!!!

But, I was bored to tears.
Seriously, where did they get that list of one hit wonders???

I want Amber gone simply because I felt like they were shoving her down my throat. Sad, because I might like her otherwise.

I should have just gone to bed...

Sent from Tracey's iPhone using DISBoards

 

[dizzwizz]

Dawg dude! I'll say anything for a price!

"Dude, you can sing the phone book." Highly intelligent !!!

 

[PizzieDuster]

Yeah girls, Final Four...

 

[Darcy03231]

Overall what a an underwhelming night. My picks are:

1. Angie
2. Kree
3. Candice





4. Amber

I know there are only four left, but Amber is such a distant 4th I couldn't put her name right below Candice.

 

[Robinrs]

Overall what a an underwhelming night. My picks are:

1. Angie
2. Kree
3. Candice





4. Amber

I know there are only four left, but Amber is such a distant 4th I couldn't put her name right below Candice.

 

[Kimberle]

Ya know why the shows bore me so much??? There are *4* singers in a 2 hour show. They stretch it out with so much filler. At this point, the show should be 1 hour. Each singer singing 2 songs. I can't stand how over produced this show has become. I miss the first few seasons when you really felt for the kids and saw their point of view. Now, it's all staged and overproduced.

The only "realness" is Jimmy's commentary. I don't even listen to the "judges" anymore.

 

[Cogswel_Cogs]

So was the theme last night, songs that people watching will never want to hear again?

 

[MIGrandma]

The only song I really enjoyed last night was Amber's first one, the Celine Dion song. Didn't care for either of Angie's, and both Candice and Kree did better with their second songs but still didn't like them much. I would put Amber first, with Candice and Kree second and third, and Angie on the bottom. I agree with the judges that Amber has shown the most improvement, and I'm starting to think she could possibly win it all.

 

[Art 1]

Ya know why the shows bore me so much??? There are *4* singers in a 2 hour show. They stretch it out with so much filler. At this point, the show should be 1 hour. Each singer singing 2 songs. I can't stand how over produced this show has become. I miss the first few seasons when you really felt for the kids and saw their point of view. Now, it's all staged and overproduced.

The only "realness" is Jimmy's commentary. I don't even listen to the "judges" anymore.

I agree. One hour is long enough. It's down to rug cutting time now. Going to be interesting to see how goes. I hope it's Angie.

 

[happygirl]

Overall what a an underwhelming night. My picks are:

1. Angie
2. Kree
3. Candice





4. Amber

I know there are only four left, but Amber is such a distant 4th I couldn't put her name right below Candice.

This are my pick as well!!

 

[Allison]

There was an article on my tvguide app about how the judges are pushing so hard for Amber to be the winner and how obvious it is.

 

[Rhody Red]

Overall what a an underwhelming night. My picks are:

1. Angie
2. Kree
3. Candice





4. Amber

I know there are only four left, but Amber is such a distant 4th I couldn't put her name right below Candice.

Exactly how I feel! I'm over Amber, and I predicted her to end up in 4th place too.

 

[Claudia1]

So was the theme last night, songs that people watching will never want to hear again?

 

[Robinrs]

Ya know why the shows bore me so much??? There are *4* singers in a 2 hour show. They stretch it out with so much filler. At this point, the show should be 1 hour. Each singer singing 2 songs. I can't stand how over produced this show has become. I miss the first few seasons when you really felt for the kids and saw their point of view. Now, it's all staged and overproduced.

The only "realness" is Jimmy's commentary. I don't even listen to the "judges" anymore.

I hate this, too. They're contracted to sell 2 hours though and who knew when this was decided that we'd have such underwhelming people to watch???

Fox NEEDS AI, it's their only high ranking show. This is the week of 4/15 numbers:

Rank 18-49 rating 18-49 Viewers (000)
1 VOICE-04/15 NBC 5.2 6549
2 VOICE-TUE-04/16 NBC 4.6 5852
3 American Idol-WEDNESDAY-04/17 FOX 3.4 4243
4 Big Bang Theory,THE 9P-SP-04/18 SR CBS 3.3 4166
5 Big Bang Theory, THE-04/18 R CBS 3.1 3925
6 American Idol-THURSDAY-04/18 FOX 3.0 3837
7 NBC NEWS SP 10P 4/15-04/15 S NBC 3.0 3830
8 SURVIVOR: CARAMOAN-04/17 CBS 2.7 3434
9 How I Met Your Mother-04/15 CBS 2.7 3402
10 Amazing Race 22-04/21 CBS 2.4 3083

Even though their numbers are down (note they JUST beat a REPEAT of the Big Bang Theory they are really ALL that Fox has to offer ratings wise.

And YES, the Voice is kicking their butts by miles!

Love my birthday boy, Jimmy! He told their sorry tails OFF last night!

 

[Robinrs]

So was the theme last night, songs that people watching will never want to hear again?

 

[kimmar067]

Sure..sing donna summer's version...and she is sucking so much we should call her Hoover.

Ouch!! Out of tune Amber...

Amber - this is a joke, right? Just bad, bad, bad.

this is bad bad baddddddddd, the notes are shrill and ear piercing. She ain't all that and a bag of chips despite what the judges think

I have always HATED that song

....I actually like Macarthur's Park, but THAT has got to be the WORSE cover of it.....EVA!



Stinkeroonie.....

 

[kimmar067]

Overall what a an underwhelming night. My picks are:

1. Angie
2. Kree
3. Candice





4. Amber

I know there are only four left, but Amber is such a distant 4th I couldn't put her name right below Candice.

....I can live with that....