American Idol: Season 11 OFFICIAL thread!

[asta]

My opinions on the girls:

Chelsea - I kind of like this. I don't know what the judges are hearing.

Erika - just ok

Jen - didn't care much for this, once again I don't understand the judges

Brielle - I liked her voice but she used odd phrasing

Hallie - Started off good, finish was a little weak but overall a good job. Hard to follow up Adam Lambert's version, he owned this song. I still remember that long walk down the pink stairs.

Skylar - Not sure about this song but I really like her personalty. She is like a young Reba McIntyre.

Bailey - I like her grandpa. Not good, just not good.

Hollie - Does she have a speech impediment? She is good.

Haley - this is awful

Shannon - I really like her but I seriously love her dress. That dress is stunningly beautiful.

Jessica - That was OK

Elise - Good job. I think she was my favorite.

 

[Robinrs]

She sounds like she should've gone with Jessica to the doctor...

Even with that she was one of the best tonight... or one of the least sucky.

 

[ShuisFan584]

A friend of mine actually grew up with Elise (lived on the same street) and graduated high school with her. So I gotta root for her!

So I want to see her, Hollie, Shannon, and Jessica move on.

 

[Robinrs]

How many go home tomorrow?

Not enough...

My opinions on the girls:

Chelsea - I kind of like this. I don't know what the judges are hearing.

Erika - just ok

Jen - didn't care much for this, once again I don't understand the judges

Brielle - I liked her voice but she used odd phrasing

Hallie - Started off good, finish was a little weak but overall a good job. Hard to follow up Adam Lambert's version, he owned this song. I still remember that long walk down the pink stairs.

Skylar - Not sure about this song but I really like her personalty. She is like a young Reba McIntyre.

Bailey - I like her grandpa. Not good, just not good.

Hollie - Does she have a speech impediment? She is good.

Haley - this is awful

Shannon - I really like her but I seriously love her dress. That dress is stunningly beautiful.

Jessica - That was OK

Elise - Good job. I think she was my favorite.

Did you have a cheat sheet?? I forgot all but 2 of them... and not for good reasons!!

 

[mandy200587]

Hollie is the one from last season that did the Climb, she has a British accent. I'll see if I can find the youtube

 

[Nancy]

I gotta say Hollie, Skylar, Jessica and Elise are my picks.


The guys I had no clear cut favorite last night.

 

[EMom]

My suck-o-meter went wild over Brielle, Bailey and Haley. I don't get the raving over Jessica, but she didn't suck.

 

[Nancy]

Hollie is the one from last season that did the Climb, she has a British accent. I'll see if I can find the youtube

In was thinking it was an Aussie accent. I remember her doing The Climb.



So, there will be wildcards too.

 

[mandy200587]

Here it is! http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U1MsiqQEqQc

 

[r3ngels]

A friend of mine actually grew up with Elise (lived on the same street) and graduated high school with her. So I gotta root for her!

So I want to see her, Hollie, Shannon, and Jessica move on.

She reminds me a little of Natasha Richardson... I loved Natasha!

 

[fairestoneofall]

based on that recap, i don't think i even want to go back and watch the ones i missed.

 

[asta]

Not enough...



Did you have a cheat sheet?? I forgot all but 2 of them... and not for good reasons!!

I kept up on my notepad then used copy and paste. That is the only way I could remember.

 

[fairestoneofall]

i cannot believe all three judges mentioned Deandre as a standout. really? REALLY?

he sucked. big time.

 

[DarthKTrava]

Not enough...



Did you have a cheat sheet?? I forgot all but 2 of them... and not for good reasons!!

Probably took notes like Steven seemed to have been doing during the show. Surprised he wasn't getting a look-see at all that leg that was in front of him from (probably) all the girls' mini-dresses.

 

[Robinrs]

i cannot believe all three judges mentioned Deandre as a standout. really? REALLY?

he sucked. big time.

They seemed to have the list to pimp. You can tell who the producers told them to promote.

With the girls it was most obvious. They want Shannon and Jessica, for sure. Pimp pimp PIMP.

At least tonight they were a bit more critical. The web had LOTS of complaints about how they pooped and peed sunshine and rainbows (don't really know the order!) so they pooped on the fodder and saved the lovefest for their faves.

 

[asta]

My favorite guy is Philip Philips so I was glad to hear that all of the judges included him in their favorites. Maybe he has a chance at wildcard if he doesn't get enough votes. It sounds like it will be tough to make the top 5.

 

[Nancy]

My favorite guy is Philip Philips so I was glad to hear that all of the judges included him in their favorites. Maybe he has a chance at wildcard if he doesn't get enough votes. It sounds like it will be tough to make the top 5.

I really liked his voice..but boy I hated what he did with that song last night.

 

[Nancy]

Oh yeah, I listened to Moves Like Jagger last night..the real version. Holy cow, are we sure that is what that guy was singing on Idol last night?

 

[Jennasis]

The girls were terrible tonight. Blech.

 

[TLSnell1981]

based on that recap, i don't think i even want to go back and watch the ones i missed.

I thought, you said "recrap". ITA

The girls were terrible tonight. Blech.

This was the only my 3rd AI show, this season. I'm not excited, over the uh...talent, this year. It may be a really short season for me.