American Idol 'Proud to be an American' question

[wovenwonder]

Did you notice that Kim L was missing when they recorded the song for the AI2 album? Wonder where she was?



And I was so OFF on picking the bottom three last night! I've never been THAT off!

Top two - no doubt in my book were Rueben & Clay

My next three would have been Kim L, Trenyce, Carmen

With bottom three being Kim C, Ricky, Josh

(this was hard for me as two of my favorites are Kim C and Josh - I'm glad I was wrong!).

Carmen was a goner --- and that is why they chose last night as the night to not kick anyone off. I'm sure they were going to pick whatever night worked for Simon.

 

[goofy4tink]

I noticed that too. Wondered if it was just my imagination. But, did I see Cory there?? My dh was curious as to how they were going to make up the extra night of programming they had scheduled if they lost two people in one week. Guess they showed us last night. Now, they're back on track. And yes, I agree that Josh was pretty bad on Tuesday. He looked incredibly surprised to find out he was safe. I think people think it's un-American to throw a Marine off! But, overall, I think Josh has been better than Ricky and Carmen, and maybe even Kimberly L. So, I'm glad he stayed last night.

 

[GoofieRuthie]

that Kim L wasn't in the recording. My girls were upest that she wasn't there but Julia was. I was also pretty shocked about the bottom 3 last night. I thought Kim L was one of best ones Tuesday night. I was really hoping that Carmen was out of there. I don't think Simon had anything to do with it though.

Anyone else feel that an hour is just a big waste of time??? I just wanted them to get to the point and get it over with.

 

[Kirby]

The Ford Explorer commercial was cute though.

Did you notice the look on Simon's face when they panned to him after announcing that no one was voted off last night? He looked thoroughly disgusted.

 

[iNTeNSeBLue98]

who did I see? I swear I saw Kim L in the studio, albeit briefly.

 

[Robinrs]

Someone mentioned in another thread that Kimberly Locke was ill during the studio time. The song was taped BEFORE the Cory fiasco...