American Idol Poll

[CruiserDew73]

Do you think it was right to kick off Nicole (scooter girl) ??

 

[damo]

I didn't really like her, but I liked her more than some of the others that got through. However, we only saw really short clips of some of the contestants so I don't think we can be very fair judges.

 

[lynxstch]

she was a loose cannon waiting to go off...and I don't think they wanted to take a chance!

 

[DisneyCP2002]

I actually did like her and wished they had kept her around another week at least.

 

[JDY]

I really liked her! She was witty, funny, talented...
Oh well, at least they got rid of what's his face. You know, the one that kept touching himself.

 

[jvas]

DW just told me Scooter girl did not get kicked off....

 

[CruiserDew73]

Originally posted by jvas
DW just told me Scooter girl did not get kicked off....

???

 

[JDY]

She did...I can see her hugging Paula now.

Check out the website American Idol

 

[katerkat]

I'm glad. She seems very unstable to me - like all that "funny" stuff is covering up major insecurities. And she annoys me.

 

[nsyncraider17]

I loved Scooter Girl and I was so upset that they kicked her off!

 

[IloveDMB]

I wasn't even thinking about how Scooter Girl got kicked off.

All I could think about was the guy with the great voice who let his BIG head get to him.

 

[CBRorBust]

She annoyed me. Her voice wasn't *that* great, it was only a matter of time IMHO.

 

[ripleysmom]

Scooter Girl while talented really wasn't Idol material. She was too hyper and did not look the part.

While I think that she can be a star someday, she needs to seriously have someone assess her look. I don't believe that she will go anywhere until she gets a makeover.

 

[CruiserDew73]

Originally posted by ripleysmom
and did not look the part.

While I think that she can be a star someday, she needs to seriously have someone assess her look. I don't believe that she will go anywhere until she gets a makeover.

I think this is the problem with the whole competition, it's focus way to much on looks...

 

[Robinrs]

The look wasn't the problem as much as her mental instability. I think getting her out NOW will be better for her than later, JMHO!

BTW, she has a wonderful voice!

 

[Mishetta]

As most said, I didn't think she had the "look" but boy could she ever sing!!! She's very talented. I hope she finds another avenue to become successful!

 

[lilsonicfan]

i hated her - i thought she was flaky... but...dont worry folks that like her, she'll probably be back in the wild card or something like that!

 

[huey duey & luey]

Originally posted by IloveDMB
I wasn't even thinking about how Scooter Girl got kicked off.

All I could think about was the guy with the great voice who let his BIG head get to him.

me too.!! here were definately much much worse people. If he would have kept his mouth shut he would definately made the 32. As far as scooter girl, I think she belongs on broadway.
Tara

 

[TigrLvsPooh]

I thought her voice was very typical for most "broadway style" singers. It's good that she lives in NYC, I'm sure she can get some gigs.

Personally, I think the judges purposely weed out anyone with training, especially classical, so she really didn't have a chance. What they really want is someone who looks hot and can sing the typical "pop style" which is a sort of urban, r&b type sound. They don't want real singers.

 

[Mimi Q]

I was disappointed that she got cut. I liked her.