American Idol..ALAINA WHITAKER IS OUT?!

[tinkerbellgirl93]

OMG, I was sooo surprised and sad when she got out. She was amazing, and my favorite. Aww man, she could've gone on to win and the judges LOVED her.

What do you thinnk?

 

[reminisce]

you may want to rename the threads title--some people have dvr'd this show and dont know yet. say spoiler, too, so people know

 

[AbsoluteAwesome1]

THANKS FOR SPOILERING.

I TiVo it.

 

[BabyPiglet]

I say, America's messing with us again. Like a certain indian guy from last season who had interesting hair. They're keeping Amanda in just for giggles.

 

[Packfan25]

I wish Robbie wouldn't have gotten voted off. Oh well, everyone has to get voted off at one point. I like David A too. I just hope he doesn't get voted off.

 

[valeriesunshine]

aww now its ruined

 

[chisnpeke]

I think some people actually like Amanda because she's different. Don't care for her AT ALL though.

I said this on another thread that I think Kady was saved because of her looks, which is a shame.

 

[RaggedyAnnPrincess]

Umm yea, you should change the title, heh. Like, ZOMG spoiler much?

 

[BabyPiglet]

I think some people actually like Amanda because she's different. Don't care for her AT ALL though.

I said this on another thread that I think Kady was saved because of her looks, which is a shame.

I understand why someone would like her if they like rock music. But her singing is so one-dimensional. I think she can only sings rock songs with lots of low notes and grunting, that's just how her voice is. Like tonight when they all sang that song as a group, I thought her voice was cracky and absolutely awful.

 

[chisnpeke]

I understand why someone would like her if they like rock music. But her singing is so one-dimensional. I think she can only sings rock songs with lots of low notes and grunting, that's just how her voice is. Like tonight when they all sang that song as a group, I thought her voice was cracky and absolutely awful.

Oh I agree that she sounds horrible. I honestly don't know how she made it into the top 24, but whatever. I guess some people are just sick of the typical pop that is on American Idol so they vote for her, but she isn't any good so they aren't really achieving anything.

 

[VMK_MagicalLadee]

GAHHHHH WHY DIDNT THE OTHER GUY GET KICKED OFF.

He pretty much MURDERED Killer Queen.
Ew.

And I like Amanda... but that elimination was ridiculous.

Ah well, my 3 favourite guys are still in XD

 

[Cassidy]

I dont watch it. But what about the fat guy who lost like 200 lbs, is he still in?

 

[BabyPiglet]

I dont watch it. But what about the fat guy who lost like 200 lbs, is he still in?

Nah, actually there's no fat people at all. There was a plus size model but she was just average sized. She got voted off the first week.

 

[Cassidy]

No. Their was a skinny guy that said he lost like 200 lbs in the audition. He was my favorite. I wanna know if hes still there.

 

[BabyPiglet]

No idea.

 

[goofyandplutoluver]

Spoiler, much? I taped this, and was actually going to watch it in a little bit. Oh well.

 

[disneychick2721]

GAHHHHH WHY DIDNT THE OTHER GUY GET KICKED OFF.

He pretty much MURDERED Killer Queen.
Ew.

And I like Amanda... but that elimination was ridiculous.

Ah well, my 3 favourite guys are still in XD

I know ! It was horrible !

 

[OneTreeHill]

I was really hoping for Kady to go. I think she did really bad and I like Alaina. I think Luke should have gone home wayyyy before Robbie, because he was absolutley terrible this week when he sang Killer Queen.
I mean, it was painful to hear.

About the guy who lost like 200 pounds, nope, he didn't even make it ot the top 24.

 

[disney100666]

I really think Amanda should've gone home instead. I don't like her at all. And she sang my FAVORITE song. yes Carry On Wayward Son is my favorite song. XD

 

[VMK_MagicalLadee]

I...I want.. someone to sing a GOOD version of a queen song other than Bohemian Rhapsody XD