They gave a glowing review, and they're pretty tough to impress! The review goes into a lot of detail about the experience and will probably answer all of your questions.
We have done it twice and love it. You basically pick your seats when you buy the tickets. We always buy them before getting to the theater. The comfortable seat and quiet theater is worth the increase in ticket price alone. The food is great to not - so - good...depending on what you order.
It is a fun experience and certainly worth doing. I agree the food is just so-so, but the chairs make it worthwhile. We had a few appetizers and a couple beers and overall it was a fun experience.