Amazed and Disappointed

Thank you for all of this ground work. It really does lay out the facts in a very concise way. It shows exactly how the hours have fallen in 2017. You are looking at about 1 hour less a day since last year, and over 2 hours a day since 2015.

I know some of the arguments here are that the attendance isn't as good. That is preposterous! There is NO WAY that June/July/August aren't the busiest months. When the kids are off, the park is busiest. Pointe finale. It is a crime to raise prices year on year, charge a premium at the MK for the summer, then close the park EARLIER AND EARLIER!

I would love to see the same breakdown for July. I'm sure it is similar, if not more brutal.

It is very disappointing overall. Summer is so hot, and weather is so unpredictable, that the slightly later hours make up for nature interfering with daily plans. I'm not saying they should stay open until midnight every night. But 11 PM as a baseline would not be terrible for them. It also spreads out the park departure a little bit, helping with the monorail and boat traffic. Some would leave after the fireworks, some after an attraction or two more, some at close. It just makes sense on SO many levels.


It doesn't sound like it really is that busy though. I expected last July to be much worse than it was. Crowd wise it just wasn't, and even in the heat, I got a lot more done than I expected. And there's nothing criminal about what they're doing. Maybe not customer friendly but not criminal:confused3. They're not holding us up at gunpoint- we can vote with our feet and not give them the money.

Just curious: how would people feel about the park closing at 11 every night with NO EMH? That would be a bigger bummer to me, but I'm wondering what others think.
 
Fortieth anniversary. Also, wasn't 2013 when they reduced evening EMH from three hours to two?
Huh? Wasn't that 2011? And even then they didn't do anything beyond the actual date of the anniversary. If you want to see a parks anniversary done right, refer to the DLR 60th anniversary. Now that affected crowds. And rightly so.
If "always" began in 1995, yes.

That's long enough for me.
 
Standard MK hours are 9-6 (don't recall the source, but I'm thinking it's one of the books since I can't find it online), so anything beyond that is extended hours. Not extending hours as much as in past years isn't the same as cutting hours.
Uh, you're going to need a better source if you're using the old "non addition" defense.

And even if we're to believe that (I don't), I wonder what ticket prices and crowd levels were when that was established.
 
Standard MK hours are 9-6 (don't recall the source, but I'm thinking it's one of the books since I can't find it online), so anything beyond that is extended hours. Not extending hours as much as in past years isn't the same as cutting hours.

Do you happen to work in a large white building in D.C.?

It wasn't a cut, just a reduction of the extension..:rolleyes2

That's like getting a credit card with a starting credit line of 500. A year later it increases to 1000. The following year they bring it to 700. They didn't cut it, they just reduced your increase from previous year?

Spin it......
 

Standard MK hours are 9-6 (don't recall the source, but I'm thinking it's one of the books since I can't find it online), so anything beyond that is extended hours. Not extending hours as much as in past years isn't the same as cutting hours.

There's a happy medium between 6 PM and 3 AM: 10:30 PM :)

Oh I definitely need you to recall the source for that one. :lmao:

And 10:30pm is your happy medium. Or is this also found within your source?
 
Do you happen to work in a large white building in D.C.?

It wasn't a cut, just a reduction of the extension..:rolleyes2

That's like getting a credit card with a starting credit line of 500. A year later it increases to 1000. The following year they bring it to 700. They didn't cut it, they just reduced your increase from previous year?

Spin it......
Please remember Dis guidelines, no talk of politics, things go down a slippery slope very fast
 
/
So, to clarify, you are doing all of the following in 6-7 hours.

Ride:
Toy Story
TOT
RNR
Star Tours
Great Movie Ride

See
Muppets
Frozen Sing-Along
Indiana Jones
Little Mermaid
Beuaty & The Beast
Music of Pixar
Fantasmic
One Man's Dream
Star Wars Launch Bay
Star Wars Fireworks

Do
Jedi Training
Eat
Use bathroom
Visit a gift shop
Walk to and from attractions


Even if you are able to teleport to the front of the line at each of the rides and magically sit down in the theater at the exact second a show starts, I would challenge whether you could do all of that in 7 hours.

No on the Music of Pixar and only Fantasmic or Star Wars Fireworks - not sure which one yet since they overlap times. No Jedi Training either.
Everything else yes starting with the 2pm Beauty and the Beast show.

*Edit: This assumes the shows don't close to capacity and based on the wait times I have seen at touringplans this isn't occurring and that HS is the real low crowd park and hence the reason for the cheaper 4 park magic ticket option to purchase.
 
Last edited:
Well, I can go on MDE right now and make a FP+ for 7DMT for 3 weeks from now with multiple times to pick from. You might be OK.

I'm always amazed when someone asks me what a fastpass is when I'm there. I encounter these people in the summer. Other than going in July due to school reasons I know better not to go at this time, lol.

I booked a magic morning so I will be ok.

edit: I just know during the heat of the day people should take a break and that the extra hours at night is very comforting.
 
Right. I don't really like to rope drop. But my point is that they still give customers plenty of opportunity to be in the parks, and at least they still have extra magic hours. Does Universal ever close later than 10?

Universal has legal and local area ordinance restrictions on them that prevent them from staying open late, since they are so close to residential areas. WDW doesn't have those restrictions.
 
It doesn't sound like it really is that busy though. I expected last July to be much worse than it was. Crowd wise it just wasn't, and even in the heat, I got a lot more done than I expected. And there's nothing criminal about what they're doing. Maybe not customer friendly but not criminal:confused3. They're not holding us up at gunpoint- we can vote with our feet and not give them the money.

Just curious: how would people feel about the park closing at 11 every night with NO EMH? That would be a bigger bummer to me, but I'm wondering what others think.

I am using the term "it's a crime" in the colloquial sense, not the legal one. :) I just happen to enjoy evenings a lot more than day times in the summer month. And I was there last July as well, and I agree that I didn't find it THAT bad (it was still very crowded.) But I don't mind crowds in general, so I can be blind to them.

I've been to Disney at Christmas time as well (as a teacher there are only two times I can go!), and they often keep the park open until 11 PM AND have EMH until 1 AM. I just don't see how the summer time doesn't deserve the same treatment. If it wasn't their busy time, they wouldn't have "peak" period pricing similar to Christmas time. And this year June's times had several 11 PM closings, where as the forecasted July closing times are almost all 10 PM. It doesn't sit right.
 
I've been to Disney at Christmas time as well (as a teacher there are only two times I can go!), and they often keep the park open until 11 PM AND have EMH until 1 AM. I just don't see how the summer time doesn't deserve the same treatment. If it wasn't their busy time, they wouldn't have "peak" period pricing similar to Christmas time. And this year June's times had several 11 PM closings, where as the forecasted July closing times are almost all 10 PM. It doesn't sit right.

This is so simple to understand but people are pretending to be obtuse.
 
I would be interested in seeing historical operating hours for the parks.

I'd be interested in park to park year over and the total number of hours between all parks. As I mentioned before, is Pandora additional hours taking away from hours at the other parks? Does management consider it as park hours en toto? It'd be interesting stuff for sure.
 
I guess I'm considered a millennial and I'm a proud millennial.

Nothing is wrong with being dissatisfied with Disney over hours. Let's face it, it's not just hours that are slipping, housekeeping, bathrooms, rides breaking down are problematic.

This whole thing that Disney can't do wrong or just be happy with Disney all the time is ridiculous.

Of course you can have an opinion that's different that's why I love the Dis. The problem is you called people whiny. It appears you care a lot about this subject.

I find the other end, the fact that everything Disney does is wrong, just as ridiculous. None of us know the ins and outs of Disney as a business. People act as if they are doing things out of spite, which is silly. Maybe the parks have not been as busy later on as they used to be, maybe they are having issues with staffing, none of us know their reasons for having the hours they have. If someone made plans based on a guess, that is their own fault. Good grief.

Just for context, people have been accusing Disney of "slipping" for decades. My uncle was a cast member in the 90s can tell you that since Disney internet boards existed (and even before), people have had the exact same complaints about cutbacks, greed, maintenance, and standards. I think people have rosier views of how things used to be, because it cannot be true that every year Disney is getting worse.

I'm not dismissing any specific individual complaints, or saying things don't go up and down. But the idea that things are getting worse is not novel or unique to today's commentators. People say it every year. If it were really a constant truth that Disney is getting worse, can you imagine how awful the place is now?

Disney World needs more nightlife whether in the parks or somewhere like Disney Springs. I really miss Pleasure Island.

Coming from the West Coast, I couldn't agree more. Calling it a night at 9pm (West Coast time) is way too early. Based on what I've read, the closure of Pleasure Island was the result of some poor decision making. Sadly, now there is not demand for more nightlife. Businesses are free to stay open late at Disney Springs, but very few of them choose to do so. One of the bartenders told me if guests were still milling about, eating and buying drinks, the business would keep serving. Several of them have tried to stay open later, but it didn't work. We need to vote with our wallets and Disney probably needs a new strategy if nightlife is the goal.

There is a happy medium between 10pm and 3am.

I'd like to see summer hours until midnight as well. But during my last visit, it really was dead in the last couple of hours.

Longer hours are directly tied to more ticket, food, and merchandise revenue. If there are extra dollars to be made, Disney will not hesitate to keep the parks open longer. Every hour guests stay in the parks, they spend a number of dollars (on whole) they would otherwise not spend. If they're closing at midnight instead of 10pm, it's not because they're just being nice or want higher costs. Every food and merchandise location reports revenue per hour. Each attraction reports turnstile clicks per hour. They have a lot of good data on how many people are being served.

Conversely, if they're closing at 10pm, they're forecasting that attendance is lower. Of course, they don't always forecast correctly (as most visitors come from offsite).
 
Conversely, if they're closing at 10pm, they're forecasting that attendance is lower. Of course, they don't always forecast correctly (as most visitors come from offsite).
Agreed. That is my guess as well, as I've shared. I'd expect them to extend hours last minute if those forecasts change -- we've experienced that in the past.

And great points about WDW having been in "decline"... at least since I joined DIS... :)

All of this is perfectly logical, but I will still tell you that I am not happy when I look at my trip calendar and see MK closing at 10pm in Aug... :(
 
Wow! Thanks for putting all that together. For a family of six (four kids although Disney adults), we will have to return to WDW less frequently than we would like to. I was planning a family trip for next summer, but I guess not. I love Disney, but with reduced hours and increased ticket prices, it looks like we will have to save up and wait until Toy Story Land and Star Wars Land opens. What will that be, like 2019???

I would not wait. Remember that hours are based on attendance. The more attendees, the longer the hours because they are more profitable keeping people in the parks to spend money they otherwise wouldn't.

Attendance in the past two years has been dropping in the mid-single digit percentages. The number of hours has also dropped by about the same. It's kind of hard to notice the exact impact of that, but you definitely will feel the impact when the massive throngs flock to WDW when Star Wars opens.
 
We arrive at WDW on Thursday for a week long stay. This may be weird, but I'm kind of excited about the early closing time at MK because that surely means crowds will be noticeably lower. Recent scans of wait times on the MDE app has confirmed this too. Sure, I wish we could hang out at MK until midnight, but I'll take low crowds and a few less hours any time. I'll be anxious to report back whether that was the case or not
 
In the winter months they've been doing an extra late night up charge at MK...I wonder if they are contemplating doing that in the summer as well? Not sure, just wondering...and wouldn't put it past them...
 
In the winter months they've been doing an extra late night up charge at MK...I wonder if they are contemplating doing that in the summer as well? Not sure, just wondering...and wouldn't put it past them...

That would be a great idea. Brings back memories of the late 80s of staying up super late and re-riding rides without getting off. Talk about a "hot" ticket though, lol.
 
That would be a great idea. Brings back memories of the late 80s of staying up super late and re-riding rides without getting off. Talk about a "hot" ticket though, lol.

It was apparently popular in February...it cost like $115 I think and included snacks and non-alcoholic drinks. I didn't do it in February because my mom and I were both tired, but if I had had my stepson and husband with me, who are both night owls, I would definitely have considered it.
 


/











Receive up to $1,000 in Onboard Credit and a Gift Basket!
That’s right — when you book your Disney Cruise with Dreams Unlimited Travel, you’ll receive incredible shipboard credits to spend during your vacation!
CLICK HERE








New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Back
Top