A) You are never stupid to buy
Trip Insurance. ANY insurance is better than none.
DCL's policy is not a bad policy. It's just that you can get better policies, with better coverage, and pre-existing condition waivers, usually for a lot less, from outside insurance companies.
B) NancyIL has alread explained why outside insurance can be better than DCL's.
C) DCL's insurance is good if all you are worried about is either getting the cost of the cruise back (or future credited) or covering medical expenses while on the cruise. If you book your flights through DCL, then that's also covered, which is great. But if you don't book the airfare through them, there's a lot of holes in what's covered.
D) If you are looking to get your money back on a cruise, and are not interested in a future cruise credit with DCL, then DCL's insurance is not a wise purchase.
E) Pre-existing condition waivers really only matter if you buy outside insurance OR you bought DCL insurance and don't want a cruise credit. If you buy DCL insurance, if your claim is denied by the insurance company (which it will be for a pre-existing condition) you will get a credit from DCL for 100% of whatever is non-refundable at the time you cancel. So if that's all you care about (getting the credit) you are good to go.
F) Some of what is covered while you are actually *ON* the cruise (like medical coverage) generally has lower bayback limits on the DCL insurance than on comparable outside policies.
G) *LOTS* of people have actually been paid, or gotten future cruise credits from DCL's insurance.
Sayhello