DON'T WORRY!!! Really, you will love the All-Stars. I say this from experience. We had always stayed in moderates, but decided to take an unplanned trip last September and the rate (49/nite) was too good to pass. As the over-planning Disney fanatic of the family, I worried all the way up to arrival that:
1.) the rooms would be too small - they weren't (me, wife, 6 yr old and 3 yr old)
2.) the theme would be cheap - it wasn't - actually the kids liked it more.
3.) food court would be sub-par - it wasn't - it was perfect - just good old American food
4.)bus service would be slow - it was not - Every day, my I would leave my wife and 6 yr old at the park and take our 3 yr old back to the hotel for a nap, then meet them later back at the park - we never waited long at all
In other words - all of our fears were a waste of energy. Too bad September 11 came along on our 3rd day - it was shaping up to be our best Disney trip ever. Now it's just the one we will never forget. A little sad to think about it. By the way, next February we are continuing our trip that was cut short last September - and assuming they have a room, we'll be right back at the All-Star Sports (hopefully Surf's Up Building again)
Hope this helps!!!