We have stayed at both the all stars and 2 different moderates and we really like the all stars. The room didn't seem any smaller than that of the mods. It was 2 adults and 2 boys. Plenty of room for us. I absolutely disagree with them being compared to Red Roof or Motel 6 - all stars are much better!! I do agree with going with the "I'm a kid again" attitude.
Have Fun!!
Have Fun!!