We haven't stayed at an All Stars but just came back from Pop and loved it! We liked the fun, energetic vibe of Pop. Room is fairly spacious with Murphy bed up, and bus system was very convenient. Since this was a 'park vacation' for us (at parks from RD to park closing), we ate most of our meals at the parks. However, in the evenings when returning from the parks, the food court was busy but didn't feel mobbed.