Advice on how to approach the school/teacher about an issue

sharona

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 7, 2008
Messages
3,422
My DD13 is in an advanced placement math class. She's in 7th grade and the class is supposed to cover both 7th and 8th grade material in one year. She has always loved math and never had any issues understanding the concepts. This year, she has seemed to struggle with "getting it" until I review it with her and explain each new type of problem. Then she is fine to do her homework. She did get an A the first term and currently has an A- average in the class but that is mostly due to the way the teacher weights the tests, homework and classwork - her test scores have been in the 80's.

Recently, when I asked why she didn't ask her questions in class, she told me that the teacher doesn't teach them, just hands out packets for them to work on and then sits at her desk. When someone asks a question, they are told the answer to the problem but not how to arrive at that answer. Sometimes they are directed to ask another student for help.

At first I thought maybe my DD was making excuses for not paying attention in class but the other day she had a few friends over and they were all saying the same thing (I did not prompt this conversation). They all said that the teacher just hands out packets and doesn't teach the new material. I asked if she reviewed the material after the packets were done - thinking maybe she was seeing how much they could figure out on their own - and they said no, there was no in class teaching/reviewing going on.

I have been trying to decide how best to approach the school/teacher/math department about this issue. To further complicate matters, today I got an email from one of the other parents that I know asking if my DD had mentioned this issue. The email went to me and another mom who responded that she has been hearing the same complaints from her DD and would be interested in pursuing the issue with the school.

Would love to hear some suggestions from those who teach or those who have had similar problems.

Should I go directly to the teacher? Email, call or request a conference? My biggest question is How to word the issue without sounding too accusatory? Or I could contact the head of the math department and let her deal with it. Is it better to pursue this individually or in conjunction with the other parents? I don't want it to seem like we got a posse together!
 
I would recommend starting with a conversation with the teacher. The teacher will most definitely have a different side to this story.

Certainly, the teaching methods for higher level learners may be different than what your child has experienced in the past.

Maybe talk with your child about how to ask for help. When the teacher is being approached for help with a specific homework question, maybe giving the answer is what is being requested, when in fact what the student wants is an explanation as to how the answer was derived.

It could be as simple as a problem with communication between the student and the teacher.
 
We had such a teacher for 4th grade. She loved to brag about how she "pushed" the kids & got them to "work independently". In reality, she just didn't show the kids how to DO any of the work. Couple of conferences didn't change anything, and in your case (like ours) it's likely this teacher has always done it this way & always will. Sorry I don't have any real advice.

Edit: I had a Chemistry professor in college who was useless in this way too. When we'd ask why the answer was what it was, he would simply rewrite the example from the book on his display board without explaining it at all. Ugh
 
First, always go to the teacher. Second, I am a middle school teacher. I don't teach math, but I have been in plenty of math classes. At our school we go in and do peer observations. I have had many kids complain to me that a few of the math teachers don't teach or explain the math problems, so we were asked as a peer observation team to go and see what we could find.

In most of the cases here, our teachers were explaining and teaching - they were just not spoon-feeding the answers like the kids wanted. This could be the case in your DD's class. However, in one class the teacher wasn't doing a great job of teaching the material so we addressed the issue and are working with the teacher.

How to word the question? I would go in and say, "My DD is having difficulty understanding some of the math. Sometimes she feels that the instructions don't meet her learning style. She sometimes feels that the packet is handed out with little instruction. Is there a better way she could ask questions so that she isn't so frustrated?"

I have a huge problem with teachers sitting at their desks, unless there is a good reason. Like, does she have mobility issues? Heck I was on crutches for 3 months and I still got around my classroom and I have risers in my room!

If the problem isn't resolved with the teacher, then go to admin.
 
Our elementary gifted program seems to work like this (they love flipped classrooms). My dd did fine. My ds struggled and is doing much better this year in a classroom where the teacher teaches.

Have you tried to use a resource like Khan Academy to help? Dd has used it for math and I think it's fairly useful.

Unfortunately I've never successfully approached a teacher about a concern like this so I just had to learn to keep my mouth shut, not send an email, and find a work around (there were times when I felt like I was homeschooling after they spent seven hours at school).
 
How long has this teacher been at the school?

Does the school do peer observations of classes?

I agree that having a conversation with the teacher is probably a good place to start. This reminds me a bit of my middle school math experience -- my teacher in 8th grade clearly hated teaching, gave us worksheets every day and then sat with his feet propped up on the desk and read the newspaper every day for an hour until it was time to dismiss us . . . We all had a lot of catching up to do when we moved to high school.
 
Our elementary gifted program seems to work like this (they love flipped classrooms). My dd did fine. My ds struggled and is doing much better this year in a classroom where the teacher teaches.

Have you tried to use a resource like Khan Academy to help? Dd has used it for math and I think it's fairly useful.

Unfortunately I've never successfully approached a teacher about a concern like this so I just had to learn to keep my mouth shut, not send an email, and find a work around (there were times when I felt like I was homeschooling after they spent seven hours at school).

I have been using online resources to refresh my memory (it's been 30 years since I was in a 7th grade Algebra class) and then teaching it to her myself.
 
Our elementary gifted program seems to work like this (they love flipped classrooms). My dd did fine. My ds struggled and is doing much better this year in a classroom where the teacher teaches.

This seems like the exact opposite of a flipped classroom to me. IME, a flipped class puts greater emphasis on doing this type of work before class, so that classtime can be used going over questions, doing a more meaningful review, etc. Teachers in flipped classes should be more engaged, not less.
 
On the surface it sounds like a lazy teacher. There might be more to the story, you never know.

I would go directly to the teacher, and do it individually (not with a group of other parents) I guess one approach might be to meet with the teacher and ask her things like, just off the top of my head here:

Set up like my daughter seems to be having some trouble (If you don't want to sound accusatory) and "what more can my daughter do to improve"?, "how can I get her to adapt"? , "how do you present information"?, "what do you do when a student has a question"? "how do you weigh grades"?

You can really put her on the spot, without sounding like you are trying to put her on the spot. If she has some rhyme or reason to her methods, it might make sense, or she might flat out lie to you, at least then you will know.
 
As the husband of a middle-school math teacher, here's my advice: Talk directly to the teacher, BUT approach the issue with the mindset that the information given to you by your daughter and her friends may be incomplete or inaccurate. This doesn't mean that your kids is wrong or any concerns might not be real, but time and again my wife has had parents come to her in a highly agitated state to try correct issues based on the things their kid has told them... only to be stopped in their tracks when my wife then provides them with "the rest of the story." This tends to be the rule instead of the exception.
 
This is kind of a flashback to my youth, (back when dinosaurs roamed the earth). One teacher stands out in my mind. He had a procedure in place.

You walk into the room and sit down.

The assignment was written on the board. It was usually outline certain chapters in the book, and do the chapter review questions. Sometimes it was a film. Sometimes it was a stack of worksheets, but he wasn't too keen on that because that required some effort to run off those copies.

One student was assigned to be monitor. That student would write down names of people who talked. That list would be turned in at the end of class and those students had to write sentences as punishment.

He would sit in the back of the room (all the desks faced forward), and read the newspaper or sometimes sleep.
 
This seems like the exact opposite of a flipped classroom to me. IME, a flipped class puts greater emphasis on doing this type of work before class, so that classtime can be used going over questions, doing a more meaningful review, etc. Teachers in flipped classes should be more engaged, not less.
Right. But the general concept is you learn at home. Do the work in class. Unfortunately it requires a teacher who can and will answer questions.
 
As the husband of a middle-school math teacher, here's my advice: Talk directly to the teacher, BUT approach the issue with the mindset that the information given to you by your daughter and her friends may be incomplete or inaccurate. This doesn't mean that your kids is wrong or any concerns might not be real, but time and again my wife has had parents come to her in a highly agitated state to try correct issues based on the things their kid has told them... only to be stopped in their tracks when my wife then provides them with "the rest of the story." This tends to be the rule instead of the exception.
I think your advice is sound. Approach the teacher with an open mind to gain information.
I would never assume school kids have the complete picture. Maybe they do, maybe they don't. Just my experience, often they don't.
 
As the husband of a middle-school math teacher, here's my advice: Talk directly to the teacher, BUT approach the issue with the mindset that the information given to you by your daughter and her friends may be incomplete or inaccurate. This doesn't mean that your kids is wrong or any concerns might not be real, but time and again my wife has had parents come to her in a highly agitated state to try correct issues based on the things their kid has told them... only to be stopped in their tracks when my wife then provides them with "the rest of the story." This tends to be the rule instead of the exception.

Please tell your wife thank you for her service to the community! I think all teachers deserve our respect and support (especially middle school - ugh) and I view the parent/teacher/student relationship as a team concept. I know that you only get one side of the story from your kids!! That is exactly why I thought DD was maybe exaggerating or making excuses. But, the other girls making the same comments as my DD really made me wonder and now the email and the other mom's response... I want to approach the teacher in a non accusatory way and get to the bottom of this. Thanks for your input!
 
Please tell your wife thank you for her service to the community! I think all teachers deserve our respect and support (especially middle school - ugh) and I view the parent/teacher/student relationship as a team concept. I know that you only get one side of the story from your kids!! That is exactly why I thought DD was maybe exaggerating or making excuses. But, the other girls making the same comments as my DD really made me wonder and now the email and the other mom's response... I want to approach the teacher in a non accusatory way and get to the bottom of this. Thanks for your input!
I can tell you that in my experience it really doesn't matter how many kids (and I am talking through high school age) have the same opinion, they may still have the big picture wrong.
I used to use the complaint or concern as a jumping off point and worked it from there with an open mind.
Occasionally they are correct. :) When they were, being careful about how I handled the initial contacts (much as you mention-non accusatory) helped if I needed to move the issue further up the chain.
 
Last edited:
We had this problem when DS18 was in Honors Math in 8th grade. For years he had a wonderful teacher, she retired and they brought in this nasty teacher who could teach Math at the younger levels, not where this group of 8th graders needed to be. DS was teaching himself. So we talked to her and she was feeding us so much baloney I wanted to throw up. You could just tell. Then each year we have the opportunity to observe a class, there were SO many parents that day in her class, we could barely move. As DS put in at the time, she put in an Oscar worthy performance and that was her first day teaching all year.

Admin was very protective of her at first bc she was good with the younger classes, and they finally confessed that she was learning how to teach high school algebra, she never taught it before. She also spent all of her time on her computer trying to save her old high school from being closed (Catholic high school)

She only lasted that year. I complained but quite quietly. There were other parents much more vocal then I was. DS18 still says she was his worst teacher ever and he has had some doozies in grade school and high school. He has also had some of the best teachers who he admired very much and learned so much from them.
 
I would address the teacher directly and not with a group. Either call or send an email and simply tell her that you're concerned that your DD is having trouble understanding the course material. Ask for her input and suggestions.

Also, does your school have afterschool extra help sessions? Our HS teachers are required to stay late a few days a week and students are encouraged to attend if they have any issues. During this time they usually work one on one with each student.
 
This is kind of a flashback to my youth, (back when dinosaurs roamed the earth). One teacher stands out in my mind. He had a procedure in place.

You walk into the room and sit down.

The assignment was written on the board. It was usually outline certain chapters in the book, and do the chapter review questions. Sometimes it was a film. Sometimes it was a stack of worksheets, but he wasn't too keen on that because that required some effort to run off those copies.

One student was assigned to be monitor. That student would write down names of people who talked. That list would be turned in at the end of class and those students had to write sentences as punishment.

He would sit in the back of the room (all the desks faced forward), and read the newspaper or sometimes sleep.

Wasn't there a guy like that in the movie Teachers? The only real work he did was cranking on the ditto machine LOL
 
Wasn't there a guy like that in the movie Teachers? The only real work he did was cranking on the ditto machine LOL

I vaguely remember that movie. Is that the one where the teacher had been dead for a few days and nobody noticed?
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom