Advice? Awkward wedding party situation

Also, unless you know someone really, really well, when they tell you to vent to them, they are just being nice. They don't really want you to. It's human nature. It's stupid, but this is what I have found to be true.
 
I've read the whole thread. While I think bride's emotions are usually high before weddings, I don't see anything here that makes the OP look like a bridezilla. I think she simply made a mistake thinking these women were her friends and would have any interest in what was going on in her life (missing dress, illness, etc.)

She was upset that she saw a nasty email about her. Who wouldn't be? She doesn't particularly want them in her wedding at this point. Who would?
She didn't care for being told someone "wanted to smack her" because her mother isn't dead. Who would?

She is not insisting their spouses be eliminated from the wedding, she still is planning on being cordial at the rehearsal dinner and wedding. Sounds like some "bigger person" going on already.

IMO, I agree with those who say get a small gift. However, IMO the reason is because these women are clearly TRYING to get in the middle of trouble. Watch your back!
 
OP you are asking about giving your remaining bridesmaids their gifts. What about your fiance's groomsmen? Isn't he giving them gifts for being in the wedding as well? :confused3 So when is he giving those out?

I think you should just give everything out at the rehearsal dinner, since you said that is customary. I do agree with the posters who said to get the ex-bridesmaids a small gift as well, after all they did step in and help with the shower (and from what you're posting now, it seems like they didn't even know you very well, so it was nice they did that.)

Hope your wedding goes well! Try to get past all these things that keep happening, and just concentrate on your special day and more importantly the marriage! :bride:
 
Out here you give the gifts whenever you want. [Sadly for my b'maids, I have taken this to mean "at least 7 years after the wedding", because I suck at gifts.] Thankfully, you are not me, but if you're not giving equal gifts I wouldn't give gifts to anyone when everyone is there. We didn't even have speeches at all at our rehearsal dinner...I tell you, things are so much more relaxed in the west, LOL. Perhaps you could accidentally forget the gifts at home/hotel room?



So the women are the wives of your fiance's friends.

So when you say "one of their husbands", you mean one of your fiance's friends, right? One of his friends did this:

one of their husbands "accidentally" forwarded my fiance and I an email where he says ...that "she" (meaning me, he used my name) is "making this wedding as stressful as humanly possible for all involved". He actually worded it with a bit more dramatics than that, with caps lock etc.

I can see why you're upset, and see why there might be some bad blood with fiance and his friend! And if there is NOT bad blood, well, I'd have a problem with my fiance if that were so!

We actually had a situation during our engagement where hubby's oldest friend hurt my feelings VERY badly, and the fact that his friend could do that to me caused my hubby to end the friendship for a few years. They only became friends again by accident, and because the friend groveled.



Why don't you be the bigger person and give them all the same gift. They may not have been their until the end, but they were there for the beginning..... In the end, you will look like the bigger person. A couple of months down the road, give your best friends another gift, just for being "them".

Yeah, that might be a better idea...

Then again, giving them designer bags...that's a hard gift, because how do you know what the style of each woman is?


Ironically, the guy had forwarded us the chain of emails between himself and that other friend, to "show us" how "mature" he was by trying to make nice with that other friend to prevent drama between the two of them at our wedding.

Eek.

I never got refunded for the first dress. The company refused saying they do credits only and they would only send me another dress, however they needed something like 3 months to get another dress to me....so apparently they thought I'd like them to send me a wedding dress after my wedding. :confused3 I'm just going to sell it at prom time. Someone will buy it.

Holy moly, that's not right!!!!

Is the shop also the manufacturer? The manufacturer should have made this right! In my wedding-planning days, brides who had their gowns ordered wrong were actually successful in calling their manufacturer, getting them to read off what was ordered, and in getting it changed! The shop messed up, and they should fix it. If the manufacturer messed up, the shop should be having them fix it. YOU should not have to accept TWO bridal gowns!



The other responded with a name calling, nasty email in which she went off on a tirade about numerous unrelated problems that she has in her life, including the fact that she "wanted to smack me" after seeing me with my mother at the bridal shower because her mom died when she was a kid and she gets jealous and was mad that I told her me and my mom butt heads sometimes because I should "just appreciate that I have a mom"... as well as telling me that I should shut up about being sick with mono because she was undergoing some sort of medical tests herself (that I knew nothing about...)... Her own husband responded to the email (he'd been cc'd) (to myself and added my fiance as well) and told her she crossed the line and to calm down.

Yikes.


I hear what you're saying, but I don't want people who I can't trust and who have very different expectations from friendship than me standing up next to me on the most important day of my life.

We absolutely agree on that! We had a blip in our relationship involving a breakup, counseling, and getting re-engaged. We went back to each of our friends and let them know that if they didn't want to stand up for us, ti would not be any sort of problem, and there would be no hard feelings whatsoever, because we take this sort of thing so seriously. Hopefully they knew we were sincere!

So I can understand why you ultimately didn't want these women standing up with you.

...I still think that their "policy on returns" should have been waived in this case (I would have, if it was my customer) , but at the same time, I understood that it was custom made and that somewhere, someone misread my order (they had a black dress with white accents instead of white with black) and that given the time frame, there really wasn't time to custom make another one. It wasn't my mistake, per se, but I should have ordered it sooner. Yes, I was infuriated but honestly, after realizing it was going nowhere, that they were an overseas custom company and that I really had no legal recourse, I decided to just enjoy finding a new dress and try to sell the other one. I love my new dress so it's all good. :)

Well, who ordered it wrong? IF you ordered it correctly, then I bet you do have legal recourse! I'm livid on your behalf. :hug:


Can't you imagine that it would be difficult to hear someone complain about her mom's involvement in her wedding, if you were unable to have yours participate at all? I can. I understand you didn't know about her situation when you did it, but now that she's told you, don't you feel bad at all?

Oh gracious...there's a period of time after you lose a parent where you feel that way, but time heals it. Mothers and daughters cannot, should not, have to be perfect and bite their tongues, just b/c someone else's mother or daughter has died. When I came back from my mom's funeral and had to deal with people in snits b/c their mother's day present might be arriving late (I did CS answering phones), I managed to keep my mouth shut about it to them. And that was maybe 3 weeks after the funeral!

It's been 10+ years now, and I just wish my mom were still around SO THAT I could have an argument with her. This woman isn't going to survive if she's still keeping that in her heart, when her mom died so young.


Maybe you are having a hard time doing that.


She is two weeks away from the biggest party she might ever throw. Before making a big committment in front of friends and relatives. She's relying on many different vendors (and one of them has failed them already), paying them lots (I assume) of money, hoping that they will do their jobs flawlessly.

She's also been dealing with a really draining sickness.

She's allowed to be a bit worried, and to not be able to let something go that's actually quite a big deal (fiance's friend being part of insulting her!!!).



OP, I'm really glad that your old friends support you. In my case, it was the opposite; my old friends had all been there done that in terms of having a wedding, and they either went for a tiny wedding or their moms planned it all. My mom was dead for 3 years when I got married, my MIL hated me, I was all alone, entirely alone, and I had no one but my fiance on my side during the planning (and sometimes he wasn't on my side about it).

It flat out sucks when people around you are over-reacting to normal reactions. When you ask someone "do these colors match" and b/c it's the second time you've asked that question (about different colors!) they refuse to answer b/c you're "overthinking" things. Ah, yeah, I am a person who thinks rust and periwinkle look FAB together...but I'm not sure ANYONE ELSE does! I'd like a mainstream opinion here on colors, LOL. My MOH called me a bridezilla and nearly started TWO arguments between me and hubby (thankfully our counseling communication managed to keep us clear on who the brat was in the situation) in the days before the wedding. Meanwhile, my vendors were calling me Zen Bride, in the fact of a heat wave causing OR to be 100 degrees with an outdoor, tented wedding.

So I've definitely been there when people over-react to normal reactions! ANd that is definitely what those two women are doing.

Focus on your honeymoon, on those last minute details, have fun, smile... Have a great wedding, honeymoon, and marriage! :goodvibes
 

I forgot to mention something. Bumbershoot is correct about the gift-giving etiquette; all those traditional wedding rules are kind of dumb...do it the way you want. I mean, if you stop and think about it, the only reason to do things the "traditional" way is bc people tell you it's tradition!

Every wedding I have been in, the bride gave me my gift informally and privately. Just pull your bridesmaids aside and give them their gifts.

I also agree with the poster who said designer handbags might not be the best choice. This is really a bit much; also, your gift should be personal, more like a keepsake. Typically a small jewelry item or personalized gift would be more appropriate.

I wish you blessings!
 
Over the years, we have been to many, many weddings. Most of those people did not last.
I'm in my 40's and have been to many weddings, too. Based on seeing the weddings and then seeing the divorces, I have drawn some conclusions:

- The bigger the wedding, the faster and more likely the divorce.

- The more the bride focused on the details of "her special day" and blew a gasket whenever something doesn't go right when she was planning the wedding, the more likely the marriage was acrimonious within the next six months and failed before Christmas.

- Of the men whose weddings I/we attended and are divorced now, almost all of them said that they should have seen it coming before they got married when their fiancee started making it all about her and it was everyone else's fault when things didn't go the way she wanted them to go. They said the attitude displayed running up to the wedding was pretty much the attitude displayed throughout their short marriage. Me, me, me, me, me, and everyone had better make me happy.

Because of what I'd seen other couples go through with these wedding blowouts and subsequent divorces, I insisted that DH and I have a small, short ceremoney with only family and very close friends attending. I wasn't about to cheapen our decision to become one by making a broadway show out of it. Our ceremony and celebration later on was short, sweet, moving and momentous.

To tell you the truth, our honeymoon bonded us more than the actual ceremony because it was just he and I making promises to each other with no spectators or audience. Just the way we felt it should be.

Getting married is all about the marriage, not the wedding. I understand about being stressed over a large wedding and will put up with a fair amount of "venting" when the bride is stressed. However, if the wedding is becoming more important to the bride than the actual marriage, my patience level with her venting goes down exponentially each time she vents to me about what's going wrong with "her" wedding.
 
I'm in my 40's and have been to many weddings, too. Based on seeing the weddings and then seeing the divorces, I have drawn some conclusions:

- The bigger the wedding, the faster and more likely the divorce.

- The more the bride focused on the details of "her special day" and blew a gasket whenever something doesn't go right when she was planning the wedding, the more likely the marriage was acrimonious within the next six months and failed before Christmas.

- Of the men whose weddings I/we attended and are divorced now, almost all of them said that they should have seen it coming before they got married when their fiancee started making it all about her and it was everyone else's fault when things didn't go the way she wanted them to go. They said the attitude displayed running up to the wedding was pretty much the attitude displayed throughout their short marriage. Me, me, me, me, me, and everyone had better make me happy.

Because of what I'd seen other couples go through with these wedding blowouts and subsequent divorces, I insisted that DH and I have a small, short ceremoney with only family and very close friends attending. I wasn't about to cheapen our decision to become one by making a broadway show out of it. Our ceremony and celebration later on was short, sweet, moving and momentous.

To tell you the truth, our honeymoon bonded us more than the actual ceremony because it was just he and I making promises to each other with no spectators or audience. Just the way we felt it should be.

Getting married is all about the marriage, not the wedding. I understand about being stressed over a large wedding and will put up with a fair amount of "venting" when the bride is stressed. However, if the wedding is becoming more important to the bride than the actual marriage, my patience level with her venting goes down exponentially each time she vents to me about what's going wrong with "her" wedding.

Yup!:thumbsup2
 
Dawn, I so applaud you for your thoughts and advice about how the OP could possibly be 'the bigger person'!!! I can see that this is so well intentioned! :goodvibes

I am not trying to disagree with you personally.
But, I do think this is something that could use more discussion.

The OP admits that she was not really close to these girls.
I believe that the comments and behaviors the OP describes are undeniably disrespectful.
I do not see this being a BFF forever situation.
Who knows how long they will even remain in the picture.

I suppose that I have to agree with the OP that her wedding day is very special, and I don't know if I could repeat my own admitted mistake by repeating it.

While I may be gracious about the fact that they are the SO's of the grooms friends... and would do my best to make them feel welcome at the wedding. At this time, I guess I can't see making them my bridesmaids, a part of the actual wedding party, wedding memories, wedding photos, forever....

I guess I am trying to say that I find the OP's feelings on this to be understandable.

OP, talk to your fiance... (they are HIS 'friends').... decide with him how you want to handle the rehearsal and wedding... do what you have to do to handle this in the most positive and drama-free way possible.

We can agree to disagree. ;) :goodvibes You are right in that she didn't know these women but she made a mistake asking them to be bridesmaids in the first place. Then she double downed on that mistake by dismissing them. I have three bridesmaids in my pictures, two whom I haven't seen for 20 years and one who I know longer speak to. Its one day out of a marriage. Its a party. An important party to be sure, but a party non the less.
 
The other responded with a name calling, nasty email in which she went off on a tirade about numerous unrelated problems that she has in her life, including the fact that she "wanted to smack me" after seeing me with my mother at the bridal shower because her mom died when she was a kid and she gets jealous and was mad that I told her me and my mom butt heads sometimes because I should "just appreciate that I have a mom"... as well as telling me that I should shut up about being sick with mono because she was undergoing some sort of medical tests herself (that I knew nothing about...)...

Sounds like maybe she was just "venting". You wanted the courtesy of being able to "vent" to a friend so why don't you BE a friend LISTEN to her and reach out instead of going "all about me".
 
I've read the whole thread. While I think bride's emotions are usually high before weddings, I don't see anything here that makes the OP look like a bridezilla. I think she simply made a mistake thinking these women were her friends and would have any interest in what was going on in her life (missing dress, illness, etc.)

She was upset that she saw a nasty email about her. Who wouldn't be? She doesn't particularly want them in her wedding at this point. Who would?
She didn't care for being told someone "wanted to smack her" because her mother isn't dead. Who would?

She is not insisting their spouses be eliminated from the wedding, she still is planning on being cordial at the rehearsal dinner and wedding. Sounds like some "bigger person" going on already.

IMO, I agree with those who say get a small gift. However, IMO the reason is because these women are clearly TRYING to get in the middle of trouble. Watch your back!

Sounds like the voice of reason to me.
 
Sounds like maybe she was just "venting". You wanted the courtesy of being able to "vent" to a friend so why don't you BE a friend LISTEN to her and reach out instead of going "all about me".

Because they didn't come to me. :confused3 They instead chose to get together with each other and their respective spouses and call me names behind my back, and then bring it up to another, uninvolved friend as well.

Hey guys, OP here. Sorry, I was away from the computer for a bit. I can't reply to all of your posts at the moment but just a few things....

Disykat, thank you.

Carly, I agree 100% on parties vs. marriage.

I actually did not want a wedding at all but my fiance really, really did. I wanted to elope alone to save money for a house. :lmao: So we compromised and our wedding has 60 guests and is completely DIY (aside from the dress) and friends helping out with photography and music. :thumbsup2

Thanks again. :)
 
Because they didn't come to me. :confused3 They instead chose to get together with each other and their respective spouses and call me names behind my back, and then bring it up to another, uninvolved friend as well.

Hey guys, OP here. Sorry, I was away from the computer for a bit. I can't reply to all of your posts at the moment but just a few things....

Disykat, thank you.

Carly, I agree 100% on parties vs. marriage.

I actually did not want a wedding at all but my fiance really, really did. I wanted to elope alone to save money for a house. :lmao: So we compromised and our wedding has 60 guests and is completely DIY (aside from the dress) and friends helping out with photography and music. :thumbsup2

Thanks again. :)

Goldie, my heart goes out to you, sugar cube, dealing with the girls that hurt your feelings and knowing that someone you love (husband) cares about someone who loves them (their hubs). I just hope you can gather up all your grace to realize that life and marriage is about compromises and being gracious to people who wrong you or for whom you do not care. I do it every day at work; there is a guy there who really has it in for me...another, more important professor. :sad2: Not to mention the family members (sister-in-law has been awful since her wedding to me)...oh!

But you can do it. Hold your head high and know you were charismatic and charming in the face of their nonsense, not a person who had to claw back.

I will add this. If you didn't know them well, and these girls were upsetting/annoying you, and maybe you felt you couldn't approach them, who would you go to? Your husband, of course. No one should ever, ever be surprised when someone breaks trust to his/her spouse. All bets are off when it comes to confiding in your honey. Of course they told their men. And the second person you would probably tell would be a good friend. That you aren't seeing this tells me you are still stuck in that bride zone.

I am guessing you are still kind of young. Not because I think you aren't mature...oh my gosh...you are really handling a lot and it seems like for the most part you are doing great with it. But because I think as you get older you might find this whole thing about not upsetting the apple cart, even when you are genuinely wronged, to be more important than being open with your feelings.

It's one of the hardest things I have learned in life!

Please don't let any drama with your husband's friends escalate. Men might dump their friends for you, or cold shoulder them, or change their opinions ever-so-subtly, but it always ends up as resentment. You are awesome, and you deserve better than this. :hippie:
 
Also, people are going to talk about you. You can't control this, and trying to think about who is/why will gobble you up. People are grumpy, or weak, or, as I said before, human. Especially those who don't know you well. That doesn't mean they are not worth knowing. When I think back to all the people who I have vented to my hubs about...or my hairdresser...wow! It never meant I didn't like or even love them, just that I had to say something to someone or I was going to blow a gasket. If I'd said it to them, the friendship would have prob. been damaged, and a friendship doesn't need to end because my girlfriend whom I love very much can not stop telling me I didn't breastfeed long enough (she did until her LO was almost 3), or because the next door neighbor lets the neighborhood hooker play basketball with all the kids in front of my house, or someone only seems to call me back when they need something. Not every feeling needs to be laid out on a table in a fairly new relationship. I genuinely believe venting to one's hubs or BFF is sometimes a better choice than breaking it down in the court of who has wronged whom.

Hugs, baby doll. :grouphug:
 
However…. Since the guys are still in, it means these girls will be at the rehearsal dinner this week with their spouses. :scared1:

If these girls have been asked to "step down" from their duties as bridesmaids, why are they attending the rehearsal dinner?

They are no longer involved in the ceremony and will be attending your wedding as guests.
 
If these girls have been asked to "step down" from their duties as bridesmaids, why are they attending the rehearsal dinner?

They are no longer involved in the ceremony and will be attending your wedding as guests.


If I am understanding correctly, they aren't just former bridemaids. If they were, it would be fine for her not to invite them. But they are also the wives of the groomsmen. According to etiquette, the OP is doing the correct thing by including the spouses of the wedding party in the rehearsal dinner. It would be rude of her to invite the men but not their wives.
 
If these girls have been asked to "step down" from their duties as bridesmaids, why are they attending the rehearsal dinner?.

Spouses and girl/boyfriends of the wedding party are usually invited to the rehearsal dinner. Their husbands are still in the wedding. Previously, both husband and wife were wedding party members. Now the husbands are, and the wives are not, but the wives will be attending the rehearsal dinner as their husbands' dates.

At least, that's how I read it.
 
Their husbands are still in the wedding. Previously, both husband and wife were wedding party members. Now the husbands are, and the wives are not, but the wives will be attending the rehearsal dinner as their husbands' dates.

Fair enough.
 
Spouses and girl/boyfriends of the wedding party are usually invited to the rehearsal dinner. Their husbands are still in the wedding. Previously, both husband and wife were wedding party members. Now the husbands are, and the wives are not, but the wives will be attending the rehearsal dinner as their husbands' dates.

At least, that's how I read it.

Yes, you always invite the spouse/SO of the attendants to the rehearsal.
 
Also, people are going to talk about you. You can't control this, and trying to think about who is/why will gobble you up. People are grumpy, or weak, or, as I said before, human. Especially those who don't know you well. That doesn't mean they are not worth knowing. When I think back to all the people who I have vented to my hubs about...or my hairdresser...wow! It never meant I didn't like or even love them, just that I had to say something to someone or I was going to blow a gasket. If I'd said it to them, the friendship would have prob. been damaged, and a friendship doesn't need to end because my girlfriend whom I love very much can not stop telling me I didn't breastfeed long enough (she did until her LO was almost 3), or because the next door neighbor lets the neighborhood hooker play basketball with all the kids in front of my house, or someone only seems to call me back when they need something. Not every feeling needs to be laid out on a table in a fairly new relationship. I genuinely believe venting to one's hubs or BFF is sometimes a better choice than breaking it down in the court of who has wronged whom.

Hugs, baby doll. :grouphug:

:hug:

See, in my case, the relationships were damaged because they did not come to me. Had they just come to me, I would have talked to them and things probably would have been different.

Communication is the most important thing in any relationship and they did not come to me. When we tried to get everyone together face to face to work it out, they refused. These are not people I care to be friends with at this point. :confused3

I don't care if they talk about me to their spouses, but it turned into them, their spouses and then one of the spouses started talking about me to several other people we knew.

I expect more adult behaviour from people in their late 30's. ;)
 
What I am saying is that maybe they didn't feel comfortable coming to you. If they felt you were getting a little overly frazzled about the wedding, I understand why they wouldn't.

Even though you felt you were growing closer, you had not yet built deep friendships with them.

Besides, Goldie, haven't you ever said something you shouldn't have or later regretted about one friend to another? You will do yourself a favor if you let this go and don't let it eat at you like this. No disrespect, mama. <3
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom