I’ve done both. The ice cream martini is good, but it’s huge and very filling for me. I wouldn’t get it again, except maybe as a dessert or if I know I only want one drink. I did not enjoy the Cold Brew black caf. The flavor of the coffee with the liqueur is good, but I had to scrape off the topping, which is made with cream cheese. I love cream cheese, but that whang on coffee was a no for me.