I love it too. We eat here for lunch on every trip (much better than dinner in my opinion). It's quiet and peaceful from the craziness of the park. It's very pretty (especially in the room closest to the street with the windows all around) and the meatball sub is yyyyuuuummmmyyyyy.
just made an adr for our first trip to Tonys, it sounds really nice. we booked it for dinner before we go into the mvmcp for a little break from the crowds and to rest our feet after a long day.