A Word of Caution to Fellow Owners

If Disney truly wants to control the rental market, why don't they just do what Marriott does. MVC will rent out members' units and keep a percentage of the rental. I know it's a large percentage, but the owner still gets income from the rental.

If DVC did this, it would keep the price each unit rents for high, and probably less points would be available for rental at a lower price. Since so many people rent for ridiculously low prices anyway, they would proabably get close to the same amount. It therefore would not be worth their time to rent on their own.

Believe it or not, most DVC owners are not on the DIS, and most have no idea of how to rent, or the intricacies of "working" DVC. In fact, a colleague of mine who convinced us to buy DVC was asking me how to rent, and what people charge per point. He was an original owner, but has never rented. So I believe, most people like him, would turn their extra points to DVC for a little extra cash. I think those casual renters without a lot of time to deal with putting together a rental, would also turn the points over to DVC for rentals. That would tighten up the supply of points available for private rental.
 
.

Can't for the life of me think what it might be...but did think it was very interesting that the info is now needed to book through CRO, too...
Perhaps commercial DVC renters have a CRO cousin, booking the best rooms and dates, and reselling them.
 
If Disney truly wants to control the rental market, why don't they just do what Marriott does. MVC will rent out members' units and keep a percentage of the rental. I know it's a large percentage, but the owner still gets income from the rental.

If DVC did this, it would keep the price each unit rents for high, and probably less points would be available for rental at a lower price. Since so many people rent for ridiculously low prices anyway, they would proabably get close to the same amount. It therefore would not be worth their time to rent on their own.

Believe it or not, most DVC owners are not on the DIS, and most have no idea of how to rent, or the intricacies of "working" DVC. In fact, a colleague of mine who convinced us to buy DVC was asking me how to rent, and what people charge per point. He was an original owner, but has never rented. So I believe, most people like him, would turn their extra points to DVC for a little extra cash. I think those casual renters without a lot of time to deal with putting together a rental, would also turn the points over to DVC for rentals. That would tighten up the supply of points available for private rental.

I think many timeshares offer a rental program similar to that, but they don't require it. In other words, you don't HAVE to use their rental program, but you can.
 
I recently called to book alot of rooms for my family reunion. They asked for the names in each unit, but not their addresses. I don't worry about it because by the:rolleyes1 time we go , depending on who wants to get the dining plan the names will all be switched again. If it makes them happy give them the names, you can always make changes later...I a;ways do.
 
When DVC was in the develpment stage, I wonder how much income they anticipated would be generated from people that did not use their points because they had no other outlet for them and therefore lost them. It could be that the ability for owners to offer their points "for rent" through various websites (Rent/Trade Board, Ebay, TUG, etc) has taken away that extra "gimme" for DVC. I'm sure the popularity of the internet has created some changes in how DVC memberships are used (regardless of personal opinions as to what's legitimate and what isn't).
Given that the DVC contract specifically allows for renting I don't think DVD ever really looked at members as having no other option but to use their points themselves. Sure, maybe they didn't envision renting becoming as easy as it is, but they knew it would happen.

It's a common thing to most timeshares, and many timeshares will even rent units out for members who won't be using them. I think Disney was wise to stay away from doing that, but had to leave the rental rights open to members.
 
DVC limiting transfers to 1 a year does not effect me or my membership in any way. I also seriously doubt that DVC stopping all rentals would effect me either. We bought our points to use them for our family vacations, as I'm sure tons of other DVC members did. If DVC wants to put further limits on renting points to stop commercial renters, that's fine with me.

I personaly don't know why anyone would feel comfortable renting from a stranger in the first place. Maybe I just am not that trusting! :)
 
You don't know where your friend lives?


I know where she lives but since I don't write to her, I don't have much use for her street address. If they wanted her phone number, no problem.

I only know my brother's street address because he lives in the house we grew up in.
 
You don't know where your friend lives?

In truth, I have friends traveling with us in June. I've known them for 15 years, I know where they live, I go to their home almost weekly, I know their cell phone numbers, I know what street they live on, but haven't the fainted idea of their house number or zip code.

Since CRO is requesting this info, it sounds like it may be for DME, so if you have more than one family under your ressie each group can call with their own flight info to a special DME phone number.
 
Once again (and it happens at least once every six months) we have the rental debate, so let me throw in some views and legal points:

1. You are legally allowed to rent with limitations and Disney is not going to do away with renting entirely. Someone who rents to offset dues, because he cannot use the points at a particular time, because he is renting to relatives, etc. (add any reason for doing it once in a while while your main intent is your own vacation enjoyment), is allowed to do so. Disney really has no intent of going after those renters.

2. Someone who owns points primarily for the purpose of renting, e.g., someone gets together with two others and they buy large numbers of points to then rent (three could buy up to 15,000 -- 5,000 a piece total, 2,000 each at any one resort), is the kind of renter who violates the rules in the offical documents because they are essentially in the business of renting. It is those types of owners that Disney recognizes as a problem. And it has to do with more than just protecting most owners who want to be able to reserve rooms for themselves. One who is considered to be in the business of renting is required by Florida law to charge and collect the resort (sales) tax that Disney charges to regular guests who book Disney hotels. The DVC owner who just rents once in a while for reasons such as those noted in 1 above is not engaging in an activity that requires the tax. As most can suspect, those who have gone into the business of renting points are likely not collecting the tax. Disney, which itself is in a business that engages in renting resort property, is the manager of the property, is the owner of the land, and has a retained ownership interest in the units, could itself face liability for the taxes not collected by those members who are in the business of renting if it were found that Disney approved of and permitted such renting. It avoids such liability by having a rule against such renting and being able to show, when needed, that it enforces those rules.

3. The new policy of asking for names and addresses of guests has nothing to do with DVC members renting. It has to to do with Disney putting into effect some recommendations relating to Homeland Security.
 
Thank you, for clarifing why Disney needs all of the names, addresses and phone numbers. Once again, it is for all of our security. As I was reading this, I was thinking, that I really did not have a problem with Disney knowing who was staying on their property. The world, as we know it, is changing before our eyes. On some of our stays, I hear a few complain about the security checks, we thank the guards. We felt much safer at Disney after 9/11 when we went and they were checking all the bags.

Happy New Year!!!
 
Thank you, for clarifing why Disney needs all of the names, addresses and phone numbers. Once again, it is for all of our security. As I was reading this, I was thinking, that I really did not have a problem with Disney knowing who was staying on their property. The world, as we know it, is changing before our eyes. On some of our stays, I hear a few complain about the security checks, we thank the guards. We felt much safer at Disney after 9/11 when we went and they were checking all the bags.

Happy New Year!!!

I don't know, I can understand Disney wanting the names of everyone (I mean, for the DDP, DME, and extra per person room charges for CRO reservations), but why in the world would Homeland Security care who I have in my hotel room...and what business is it of the US government, especially if I own the points? What's next, implanted GPS tracking chips?
 
This usually involves two or three rentals a year since I only own about 726 points. And I do not make the reservations 1st. I let the renter choose the dates as it should be...Y-ASK

Y-Ask,

Just to be clear IMO there is nothing wrong with what you are doing. That same thing is basically what I had done over the past twelve years. Difference is I booked peak weeks and then rented the weeks getting a far higher price per point.

How is that wrong? I booked those weeks with MY points during the home resort priority period of 11 -8 months in advance. I paid dues on those points so why can't I use them as I see fit? I've asked this a lot and still havene't seen a good answer. What is the difference if I rented those weeks or used those peak weeks for myself or as giftf for colleagues and family? Those weeks are still unavailable at 7 months no matter who uses them.

In short why can't a member use there points as they see fit?
 
But Disney is also unique in the industry. They are selling timeshares that in essence compete with their thousands of cash-paying rooms.



I disagree.

ALL Timeshares rent rooms for cash. They all allow members to rent and many like Marriott will do the renting for the member albeit for a high fee of 40% or more.

Also DVC rooms are completely different than the hotels at WDW. Many guest to WDW do not even know that you can pay cash to stay at one of the DVC Resorts. CRO can't even move the inventory they have now when it comes to DVC rooms. I could have gotten a room at OKW, SSR and BWV for this November on 1 weeks notice. All had one and 2 bedrooms left and maybe a studio at one. I was contemplating a last minute stay so I checked.

I guess I just don't see a room at POP being competition for DVC.
 
I think that Disney will be doing all of its members a big disservice if they significantly restrict renting when you do not get a resonable value for your points for trades outside of the DVC resorts. If you finance your purchase your cost is significantly higher than the dues and orginal cost which is approximatly $7 per point. For example if you run an amortization schedule over the term of contract at say 7% you find that your cost is over $10 per point. When Disney gives you a value of less than $7 per point for a trade like DCL it is very hard to stomach using points. We all have invested a lot of money in DVC just to pay more for a cruise than a non DVC member who purchases from a travel agent. I may be wrong but I believe that Disney make a good profit when they sell those points that cost them less than $7 per point for a trade. If you take away renting then it reduces the value of ownership. When we purchased I thought that it would be great to trade out and go to other places but I now realize why a lot of veterans recommend buying a non DVC timeshare for trades. I hope in the future we get a better value for our points which will reduce the number of points that are rented out.



This is a fantastic post!!!!!!!

All of these people ranting how renting should be done away with should really think hard about this.

How about I take away something you really like about DVC, like annual pass discounts or pool hopping? Very easy to want to do away with something you don't use personally. You never know when you may want to or need to rent so don't be so quick to dismiss it.

Any changes restricting use of our DVC devalues the product. DVC had better be careful with this or these "changes" and restrictions may start to hurt new resort sales. DVC being one of the most flexible Timeshares may have to be rethought.
 
I disagree.

ALL Timeshares rent rooms for cash. They all allow members to rent and many like Marriott will do the renting for the member albeit for a high fee of 40% or more.

Also DVC rooms are completely different than the hotels at WDW. Many guest to WDW do not even know that you can pay cash to stay at one of the DVC Resorts. CRO can't even move the inventory they have now when it comes to DVC rooms. I could have gotten a room at OKW, SSR and BWV for this November on 1 weeks notice. All had one and 2 bedrooms left and maybe a studio at one. I was contemplating a last minute stay so I checked.

I guess I just don't see a room at POP being competition for DVC.
To a degree I think you are correct. To say all rent for cash would likely be a stretch but certainly most don't directly compete in a significant way with their other cash business even for those with a hotel and timeshare linked together though there are exceptions. But I think Disney is somewhat unique in the degree of the issue in that there is a fair amount of direct competition when DVC is concerned. First, Disney is competing with itself when it sells the timeshare as those are often the people that would come time and again to Disney anyway. Then they compete at CRO offering both DVC and non DVC options. Lastly the members that rent or let others use their points are taking away potential cash renters.

Actually I agree that these are not problems from our standpoint but they are potential problems to Disney as a whole. Obviously Disney has decided the positives to them of having a steady locked in group of visitors, not to mention the significant income up front, is worth it. But if you are the Management type that must defend your resort when occupancy and revenue is down from your direction, you may feel otherwise. And in part this could and should work to the members advantage in that less occupancy could create willingness to deal. But it could also lead to some hidden resentment resulting is less willingness to deal.

And I enjoy the fact that essentially any effort to curtail the very small number of owners who are renting in this way will actually affect the membership as a whole in a negative way likely more than it does most if not all renters.
 
A reminder...this thread is about listing all the names and addresses on a ressie, not about debating the pros & cons of renting. Please return it to topic.
 
In addition to possible security reasons, Disney could use the names / addresses for follow-up advertising for DVC and other Disney entities.
 
2. Someone who owns points primarily for the purpose of renting, e.g., someone gets together with two others and they buy large numbers of points to then rent (three could buy up to 15,000 -- 5,000 a piece total, 2,000 each at any one resort), is the kind of renter who violates the rules in the offical documents because they are essentially in the business of renting. It is those types of owners that Disney recognizes as a problem. And it has to do with more than just protecting most owners who want to be able to reserve rooms for themselves. One who is considered to be in the business of renting is required by Florida law to charge and collect the resort (sales) tax that Disney charges to regular guests who book Disney hotels. The DVC owner who just rents once in a while for reasons such as those noted in 1 above is not engaging in an activity that requires the tax. As most can suspect, those who have gone into the business of renting points are likely not collecting the tax. Disney, which itself is in a business that engages in renting resort property, is the manager of the property, is the owner of the land, and has a retained ownership interest in the units, could itself face liability for the taxes not collected by those members who are in the business of renting if it were found that Disney approved of and permitted such renting. It avoids such liability by having a rule against such renting and being able to show, when needed, that it enforces those rules.

[/QUOTE]

I would be very careful about giving advise on who owes the use tax. I know from several conversations with state and county use tax auditors and tax professionals that the above information is not totally correct on who owes the use tax. Each member should do there own reserach. The state of florida has some specific rules on their website on who owes the tax.
 








DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom