50 PTC or MM - HS lunch ADR

[nklooz]

Any thoughts? I have been wanting to try MM, but we are also doing Tony's in MK and I'm afraid they'll be too similar. However, I can't decide if 50's PTC seems exciting or not. It's me, DH, DD12, and DD2. Any thoughts are appreciated! Thanks.

 

[PyxiiDustt]

50s PTC is a must do for us every trip. I absolutely love the atmosphere, the food, and the milkshakes. It's my favorite restaurant in WDW, tbh. So my vote is for there

 

[photobob]

I like them both, but if you are doing Tony's and don't want to do two Italian restaurants then do 50's PTC. Their food is very good and the atmosphere is very neat. I've eaten at both multiple times and never had a bad meal.

 

[canadianmom2three]

IT was our first time at 50's this past trip (2 weeks ago), and we were charmed. The food was really really good, the milkshakes were delicious, and the atmosphere was lots of fun. Our kids (10, 12, 14) loved the server, and we would definately go back.

 

[CR Resort Fan 4 Life]

I have been to 50's Prime Time Cafe multiple times for both Lunch and Dinner, so I would highly recommend it.

 

[mdelano4]

It's a coin toss between MM and 50PTC. I would, however, skip Tony's. It's one of only 2 places in WDW I will never return to (the other is H&V).

It's been 4 years and I think the manager must be investigating the hair I found in my pasta, because we still haven't seen him/her.

 

[Hopefully]

If you are doing Tony's at the MK I would definitely do the 50's PTC. It is great fun and the food is very good.

 

[memakwed]

We've done both. Last trip we did both in fact. 50's is good if you're ok with a more active environment but I like MM if you just want to sit and have a break. I think the quality of food is better at MM. THe wait for a seat can be a bit longer at times but the atmosphere takes you out of the manic park feel.

Last trip to 50's was excellent thought and we had the best waitress yet. We even had homework and had to come up with a fruit or veggie for every letter of the alphabet so something for the kids to do while you wait for food. The younger can color and the older occupied but again not everyone gets a great waitress.

I would pick MM plus you could add a fantasmic package to it too. Can't do that with 50's

 

[nklooz]

Thanks everybody! It sounds like the hustle bustle and atmosphere of 50s would be fun for the 12 yo and the 2 yo. Plus, the milkshakes sound great! We will go with 50s. I appreciate the feedback!

 

[canadianmom2three]

Thanks everybody! It sounds like the hustle bustle and atmosphere of 50s would be fun for the 12 yo and the 2 yo. Plus, the milkshakes sound great! We will go with 50s. I appreciate the feedback!

Mmmm try the pb&j milkshake!!