I have mainly stayed on-site as well: CBR, ASM, GF, OKW, BC, SOG and our most recent trip, this year was at OKW and the Dolphin. The Wyndham Palace was located close to Downtown Disney. We made a trip with my extended family and stayed at Shades of Green but it was our anniversary and I thought it would be nice to spend one night apart, and this is when I got the one night at the Wyndham Palace. Coming from Shades of Green, the Wyndham was a "let down". The hotel parking (non-valet) was quite a hike from the hotel lobby (so I would recommend paying for the valet). There was nothing particularly wrong with the Wyndham Palace but it was just a large hotel with what looked to be alot of people on business. It didn't have a resort feel to it and I don't remember the service being great, but nothing notably bad either. Guess you could say it wasn't "magical". I didn't try the transportation to the parks or the pools or anything else other than the room, so maybe that's why it just seemed like a regular hotel to me. If I had the choice between not going to WDW or going and staying at the Wyndham Palace, I would go with the Wyndham - it's not like it was so horrible I wouldn't ever stay there again. But I would probably pick a moderate WDW property and possibly even the All Stars over the Wyndham Palace.