4 night Dream Vs. 5 night Magic

[GatorMomInNC]

which would you do?

Dream
Pros
$300 cheaper
Never been on the dream
Would complete "grand slam"
Star Wars theme in kids club (this is a cruise during PremEar of SW8)
Prefer Aquaduck to Aquadunk

Cons
Prefer smaller ships
Too short

Magic
Pros
Only $300 more for one more night
Favorite ship
Get to see "Tangled" again

Cons
Leaves out of Miami, so couple 2-3 hours more drive

 

[Kim&Chris]

I sailed the Dream a few times, and really missed the feel of the smaller ship. Plus, the adult pool is better (JMHO) on the Magic/Wonder.

I'll always chose the Magic over the Dream.

 

[cruisehopeful]

Based on your pros and cons, I think you would rather be on the Magic.

 

[tink1970]

I prefer smaller ships too but the PremEar of SW8 sounds fun! Plus you'll have the grand slam for a few years until 5 & 6 come out..and $300 towards funding your next cruise!

But if you really want the Magic, well... the heart wants what the heart wants

 

[Rabb it]

Sounds like you're leaning towards the Magic

 

[Princess Minnie of Disney]

I personally choose the Dream cruise since it sounds a lot more unique and it would be your first time! Plus as other posters mentioned you can start saving for another cruise or put in to spending money on board (cooler port adventures, shopping, drinks). Hope this helps!

 

[egesicki]

Extra night, and I also prefer the smaller ships.

 

[Hundredacre]

Dream. Kids prefer it.

 

[Laundress]

I would do the Dream. SW8, kids club, Aquaduck, Grand Slam to top it off.
Makes for nice memories. You are sure to enjoy yourself either way.

 

[GatorMomInNC]

Thanks everyone. I do love the Magic, but I think I will step outside my comfort zone and give the dream a go. Grand slam, baby!

 

[Ms95014]

Go for the grand slam!