2nd MNSSHP or...

[mummabear]

Would you go to a second MNSSHP (we have tickets for the 1st already) or head to chip and dales campfire and trick or treat the campsite?
I am confident that this will be our only Halloween time trip to WDW so want to see "all" of MNSSHP and am mindful I am unlikely to fit it all in during one party but I am also running out of evenings and think this might be my only time to fit in the campfire.

 

[ameliahyde]

If you are able to stay at MNSSHP late, and don't leave right after fireworks, I think you can do most, if not all, of the party. We went two different times, and one time we stayed until well after midnight. That time, we saw the parade, fireworks, hit just about every treat station , rode a bunch of rides, and met the princesses with the princes. The other time, we left just after the fireworks, and did not hit all the treat stations, but did see the parade and the dance party in tomorrowland. I would not recommend doing the party twice in the same trip given the expense and the fact that the two premiere parts of the party (fireworks and parade) are easy to catch. In addition, the candy is fun but it is your typical stuff - nothing unique to Disney.

 

[OhThePain]

I agree that if you can stay the length of the party, you can pretty much see and do just about everything you could want to with the party. The only thing that can pose a problem is if you want to see both Jack and Sally and the 7D, since both lines begin to form long before the party starts and remain pretty long lines throughout. Other than that, there is nothing that can keep you from seeing the villains' show, Boo-To-You, HalloWishes, the dance parties, the trick or treat trails/stations, a few rides, etc. in one party, IMO.