1900 Park Faire or Cape May Cafe? Which would you pick?

[jenniferma]

Of the two restaurants-- which would you select for a dinner buffet-- Cape May Cafe or 1900 Park Faire? We are doing a lot of Character Meals, so either way is fine.

thanks! (smiley by dd5)
jen

 

[frozone]

Depends on what park I would be touring that day, but as a blind pick, I'd go for Cape May. But I love seafood so it wasn't a hard choice.

 

[lovinpoohbear]

only did 1900 park fare.....dinner was mediocre at best and very noisy.........it wasn't at all what we expected

 

[pbharris4]

Doing 1900 PF this trip for the 1st time, but we ALWAYS do Cape May Cafe for breakfast and dinner every trip. Sometimes we go 2x for dinner. It's good, casual, and we just like it. We've eaten there maybe around 10 times in the last 3 years maybe. You must try the Oreo Bon Bons!

 

[SqueakyMouse]

1900 in a heartbeat! The food is awesome. I could make a meal out of just the soup and salads here! The pastas prepared to the left of the serving area are also fantastic.

Last visited CM in May. No one in my party of 5 was impressed. Of course, we are all originally from the coast; so we were expecting a little something more from a seafood buffet. It wasn't really bad, just not too exciting for us.

 

[HopperFan]

Lots of factors......

1900: I expected the atmosphere to have more to it - maybe be alittle more "proper", wait staff seemed rushed and pushing those expensive drinks, I had to request the music be turned on, food was good but not great. Kids loved it and was a memorable dinner but no rush to return.

Cape May Cafe: Actually went with another family from another state and we were not rushed and had a wonderful visit, food was good (again if you are from the NE Coast you may be disappointed), excellent service, nice atmosphere, relaxed. Will return for overall experience.

 

[abaldacci]

hands down 1900 park faire

 

[FlowersChild]

I would pick 1900 Park Fair only because Suzy and Perla are at 1900 Park Fair and Suzy and Perla are my 2 favorite characters that come to WaltDisneyWorld I just had my first character meal with Suzy and Perla and I have 10 more character meals booked at the 1900 Park Fair just so I can have more character meals with Suzy and Perla