We were in WDW twice last year, January and May. January was the first trip we tried 1900 Park Faire for dinner, we hadn't known about the CInderella meal. We loved it. THe guys in our group thought the prime rib was great. They character interaction was really good and our 3 year old DD had a great time. We made a point to go back there in May too.
We are going this year in May and that is our first reservation of our trip.