Definitely 1900 Park Fare. Chef Mickey's is one of the few restaurants I will never go to again. We had an ADR for 7 people (4 adults and 3 little ones). We were seated over an hour past our ADR time, our service wasn't great, and the food was terrible. The restaurant was just pure chaos. Kids were running around all over the place, the floors were sticky. It just thoroughly grossed me out. 1900 Park Fare is a much better experience overall. I love the food (especially the strawberry soup), our service at breakfast was great, and I know you said character interactions aside, but the characters at 1900 Park Fare (breakfast or dinner) are second to none.