We had dinner at Mama Melrose with the Fantasmic dinner package. This works out well on the dining plan because you get an appetizer per person, the meal, and a selection of desserts.
Here are the appetizers:

My mother in law ordered the Vegetarian Minestrone. She said it was good!

Two people may order the Mama's Antipasto to share. My DH and FIL shared this. We all actually nibbled on it. It was very good!

Niece ordered Crispy Calamari. It came with a few dipping sauces. I think she thought they were just okay, but my DH said they were good.

BIL ordered the mussels which are not listed on allears as an appetizer. I think they were good, he ate them all!

Fresh mozzarella and vine ripened tomatoes. Also very good!

This was mine...the caesar salad. It was good, and I loved the big crouton!
And for the main courses:

Charred Strip Steak--DH ordered this. It was VERY good. Very flavorful. I snagged a few pieces.

FIL ordered Braciola Di Maiale - grilled pork chop with apple-mustard butter and potato watercress salad over broccolini. I was surprised, because he doesn't like broccoli, or onions, or anything funky really! I think he liked the pork though because he ate that.

MIL and SIL both ordered this. Penne alla Vodka. SIL got chicken in hers. They both loved this. The portion was huge though and they actually could have shared one dish!

This was my dish. The Chicken Parmagiana. I was torn between this and the Pollo Di Forno chicken dish and asked the waitress her opinion. She said the chicken parm was her favorite. Ugh...I didn't love it. In fact I barely even liked it! It was pretty tasteless IMO. And the spaghetti was weird. I'm not sure how to describe it. It was watery under my plate, but was extremely al dente. I ate maybe half.

Kid's pizza. My youngest DD loved this and ate almost the whole thing.

BIL ordered this Pesco all' Acqua Pazza - Fish of the day in a spicy tomato butter sauce, fennel, peppers, and tomatoes served over basil gnocchi pasta. I don't remember what the fish of the day was, but he LOVED this. Couldn't stop raving over it after every bite!

Kid's chicken parm. DD7 ordered this and ate almost all of it. She loves chicken parm...it's her favorite thing!

Adult spaghetti and meatballs. Niece ordered this and it was just okay she said. Probably the same spaghetti issue I had!

Kid's spaghetti and meatball cupcake. My DD5 ordered this. If you remember correctly she is extremely picky and has some feeding issues. So she was not thrilled with this. It had too many textures and the strawberry sauce drizzled on it was the deal breaker. That's okay...good thing for mommy

I thought it was GREAT! I loved the strawberry sauce on it!

These were the shared desserts they brought for all of the adults. They brought two plates like this for us to share. I didn't love any of them and was happy with the cupcake! Everyone enjoyed them though.
Overall, some in our party thought this was the best meal of the week. I would not hesitate to return here, but would definitely order something different. The Fantasmic! package is a great deal on the dining plan since it's one credit and you get an appetizer too.