Personally, we prefer BCV for the location and nearby activities. But you'll want to make sure you have enough room for your group. A one bedroom won't be enough. If your planning on having two one bedroom villas, one for each family, personally you'll have plenty of room whichever resort you choose, I'd pick WLV if you'll be going to MK, or BWV or BCV if you'll be going to Epcot and MGM more often. The crescent lake area is wonderful, tons to do close by. Lots of eating options. People can go thier seperate ways the then regroup. With the younger kids, we find ourselves taking an afternoon break, and it's great to be close by your resort to be able to do that easily, and then head out to another park later on. But that's us, OKW owners like thier resort too for lots of good reasons, it's just not our top choice, in fact it's probably our last preference. But that's just us.