Tough decision! Both resorts are great and have a lot to offer, but having stayed at both within the past 18 months I'd vote for POR. There's just, in my opinion of course, more to do for younger children. DD was 18 months when we stayed at POFQ and I found the size of POR and POFQ combined to be manageable, she loved the pools and playgrounds and the Clydesdale horses. We stayed at CSR two months ago and while I loved the overall feel of the resort and the rooms, it definitely does have a convention feel. On our second morning there a convention was just checking in and the crowd was massive. If it were just me going, CSR it would be, but with DD in tow I'd pick POR any day of the week!