Wow, I did not know there were DISers close by! we had table #3 second seating We actually liked that table. In RP, it was in a semi private room and was very relaxing and quiet. Both AP and EG were both in the forward port side and away from the babble of the main dining room. Now if we had the server from table #4 we would be happy! Both of those guys were really interacting with the table, ours (though fine) were straight-laced (from Hungary). Getting ready to book the Magic 2 night cruise out of NYC for 2012 (which was not available for booking on the cruise )