NOTE: Now, would 1/4" make a difference in physiology or restraint systems. Probably not.
With the way they're specified and padded,
absolutely not.
However, you have to have a set "number" somewhere, and stick to it. Otherwise, someone can say that their child misses the height only by 2"-4".
I agree with this statement 100%. I'm not arguing that CMs should allow kids a little too short to "slip by." That way madness lies; it's a classic slippery slope situation.
My point is that it's false to say or imply that a child tall enough to "slip by" wearing padded shoes will be in any danger. He/she won't be.
I debated responding again b/c everyone has a right to do whatever they want, but coming onto a PUBLIC forum and calling people who are following the rules "nosy strangers" and "utterly naive" is not nice.
Those of us who are willing to help our children get by a measuring stick that they are very close to passing anyway were being called bad parents. I responded in kind with the "nosy strangers" comment. I don't want or appreciate a stranger telling me that I'm risking my child's safety when I know for a fact that I'm not.
The "naive" comment was not the same, and you misquoted me anyway. What I said was: "It is hopelessly naive to believe that if (for example) 44" is "safe," that 43" is unsafe." That's true, though I can understand how those who feel that way might be offended that I consider them naive.
I think someone should end it and just call Disney and ask them if it is OK to wear thicker soled shoes ON PURPOSE, pad their shoes, put their hair up, whatever to get on a ride? Report back, OK.
As I explained before, I'm not saying Disney would approve, or that they should allow those just short of the requirements to slip by. They have to set the line
somewhere and then enforce it as consistently as the situation allows. But
my attempt to get a child by the measuring stick is no business of
yours. I'm not endangering my child's safety, and I'm not hurting any of those "better parents"
out there that think Disney sets minimum heights right at the safety limit.
David