The previous poster who's bank advised not to use pay at the pump (the poster had previously had fraudulent activity reported on the account) was probably advised not to use "pay at pump" as the credit card may still be on "fraud watch" by the bank. Pay at the pump in this instance, would set off an "alarm bell" (due to the criminal usage of pay at the pump). However, this is would be a unique situation, and far from normal.
I sucessfully used pay at the pump for years, ever since it first became available. Years. I never had any issue. I've always been super careful, covered my pin, shredded every peice of mail I've gotten...
Then one day, I got a call from the bank, they had cancelled my card. And, they issued a new one... I wasn't on any type of "fraud watch".
I, being quite confused about how this could all happen, asked where the number had been taken from... and how it could have been used, how it could have been compromised so I could avoid it happening again.
They told me to avoid using my Visa or debit at any gas stations inside or "paying at the pump". I may be wrong, but I just thought I'd pass on the information they gave me.
While I wasn't liable and they did eventually "pay" for the other charges that weren't mine, it took a while to sort out. Although they alerted me, and I knew nothing about the fraud, they took all avenues they had available to insure that it wasn't me making the crazy charges and withdrawls... And, I was put through some financial strain since my debit had also been compromised. So, I figure I'll let y'all know... because I wish someone had told me.