If you want a signature, we love Jiko, Narcoosees, and CA Grill.
I have heard great things about The Wave and Kona Cafe, but we haven't been to either yet.
I think it also depends on who is going...kids? adults only? etc.
Ohana is a favorite of others, but not ours. I'm thinking kids would love it. Also, I think the Cape May Clam Bake sounds good if you are seafood fans.
Are you totally sold on Chef Mickey's? We weren't pleased at all (and we are in no way picky or snobbish about restaurants). If you are looking for the "Fab Five," perhaps Cape May Cafe for breakfast would be a better bet. Just an idea. Have fun!