Not trying to argue with you, but genuinely curious...if you haven't seen it, what makes you classify "A Christmas Story" as stupid humor when you admit to enjoying The Santa Clause? When someone says 'stupid humor' to me I usually assume they mean the sort of slapstick, fall-down-and-laugh type of comedies...just wondering what your definition is.
White Christmas
A Christmas Story
Muppet Christmas Carol
Patrick Stewart's version of A Christmas Carol
A Charlie Brown Christmas
A Claymation Christmas
A Muppet Family Christmas
How the Grinch Stole Christmas
Only seen Elf once, but I liked it
Technically, I don't consider It's a Wonderful Lice a Christmas movie.
My top 3
1. National Lampoons Christmas Vacation
2. A Christmas Story
3. Elf
Bad Santa gets an honorable mention