Since the opening of both Il Mulino and Via Napoli, we get our fill of Italian food there, so we never get the urge to go to Mam Melrose. It is far below the quality of these other two. So we prefer to go to 50's, as the food and atmosphere provide much needed diversity. That is not to say that Mama Melrose is bad. But 50's simply provides a more unique Disney experience. Neither place is going to win a James Beard award any time soon. So the "fun factor" comes into play, and in that regard, 50's wins.