micknpluto -
I didn't read all the text in that link yet, but how could Andrea be brought back? As a ghost, like Lori? Or how would it work?
I don't know. I do get attached to characters to a certain extent, but as I've mentioned in this thread before, this is the one and only show where I don't mind if major characters get killed off! Even if it's heartbreaking or upsetting - even if I like the character - I love that
TWD is basically the one and only show on TV that is not afraid to kill off major players at any ol' random time during a season.
Other shows would either back away from killing off any of their major stars, OR they would wait until the season finale to do it, OR they would wait until the series finale to do it, OR they would kill off one major person and no one else, OR they would make us think someone was dead and then they would bring them back.
TWD defies all of those typical plot points and does its own thing. Even "Lost" backed down from killing off too many important people during the course of the series (Jin & Sun didn't go out until late in the game).
The fact that anyone could go at any time on
TWD is one huge reason I love the show. In the zombie apocalypse, no one is 100% safe. Unless a new world is created for/by the survivors, chances are they will probably all die eventually (though we may not see all of it happen on the show). They know they're on borrowed time. That endless sense of 'who's it going to be next' adds to the tension and suspense for me, because I know it could be someone I like. If
TWD suddenly stopped killing off people for whatever reason, or became too formulaic, I'd think they were selling out. I don't expect that
TWD (with the current cast and setting) will run for more than 5 or 6 seasons at most, because the premise of the show is simply too dire.
Of course, AMC or another channel could bring back
TWD with an all-new cast in an all-new location, so it would be sort of like the same series but different at the same time. That would be an interesting idea.
Another sort of 'gloomy' show I love is "
Breaking Bad." There is no question in it that the lead character (Walter White/Heisenberg) is going to die in one way or the other, and that other people will die along the way. It's just a matter of who and when and how. But it was pre-determined that the series would not run too long - it's only going to be 5 seasons in total - because there is only so long they can drag out this rather dangerous storyline without the lead character getting killed or dying some other way. It would be illogical to try to find ways to keep the show on the air.
So I think that on
TWD, it wouldn't be true to the nature of the concept of the series to keep too many people alive.