From everything I've read, if you're used to DVC villas, you won't be happy in a WDW Value. That said, we're just back from AoA. Due to jobs, kids, commitments, and that pesky thing called a budget, we don't get to WDW as often as we'd like - on average every 4-5 years. With the oldest about to leave for college, this was our last big family trip. We're also the type of family who spends at least 10 hours in each park each day in order to hit all the rides, parades, and shows we want to see. All that said, we found the AoA family suite to be the perfect fit for our family of 5. There was no issue with sleeping kids - mine don't wake up when I check on them at night to pull up kicked off covers, etc. so walking into the living/dining area when they were sleeping didn't cause a problem. At night, Hubby and I finished getting ready for bed in our own bathroom/bedroom after they'd gone to bed. The kitchenette was perfect to fix breakfasts (saving some bucks; lunch/dinner were on the free food plan). Kids did manage to swim 3 of 6 days (it was in the 50s at night), we ate in the food court, and I did laundry one night - no difference between POR and AoA that I experienced in any of those categories. We even went over to SSR for the DVC presentation, and I was shocked to see some of their one-bedroom layouts provided LESS sleeping space for a family of 5 (1 queen, 1 full sofa bed, 1 chair sleeper (smaller than a twin) versus 1 queen and 2 full convertables).
For many who aren't used to waiting for buses, doing laundry outside their unit, want to spend time by the pool, want/need a full kitchen, you shouldn't stay at anything less - even Moderate or Deluxe without the suite option won't work for you. If you've ever lived in a dorm or apartment, take public transportation to school or work, go to Disney for park time not pool time, and are on a budget, AoA is a great choice!