Love the thread! I think I just saw more of the Poly than when I was there
We went during President's Week, which was the slowest I've ever seen Disney and everything was open late! Sadly, we were both sick and only had 2.5 days there to boot. I've wanted to go to the Polly for several years and it was sort of a mixed bag.
Loved:
Large rooms
Watching the fireworks from the top of the stairs at the end of my building
Monorail and boats to MK (and also to the Contemporary for breakfast)
Relaxed feel outside and beautiful landscaping
Not having to go to MK just for Dole Whip
Wasn't impressed:
Main building was loud and a bit confined despite it not being very busy
Not having a sink outside the bathroom
Monorail to Epcot (found it quicker to drive there)
Rooms seemed louder than other resorts, which i chalk up to 1970s era construction technology.
No spa services (and GFL spa was closed at the time)
I'm a fan of the AKL, so I think that skews my opinion a bit. I just didn't feel like there was the same level friendliness from the staff as I've experienced at AKL(don't know how to quantify that), and of course I've been spoiled by staying in a much newer resort the past few trips. I did enjoy it, but felt a little let down since I had built it up in my head so much.