Okay, so I finally have some time to write a bit more about our trip! I should be on my way to drop DD off at daycare and head to work, but she is still sound asleep and I'm not gonna wake her - she needs to catch up, and honestly, I don't care if I'm late to work today.
We were at the Poly from 5/5 - 5/12 and I have to say, despite a few very minor glitches, it was wonderful! We were in Rapa Nui, connecting rooms with my mom. We thought the rooms were HUGE, but yes, a bit on the dark side (seemed like we had to have every light on and the curtain open to read easily). The only issues we had were that the shower curtain rod was drooping in our room (seemed like it needed to be reattached to the wall, but it was fine) and that the TV in my mom's room didn't work (but she got a quick response from maintenance when she called and had it fixed - she likes the news in the mornings). Housekeeping did an 'eh' job - no towel animals, but they did spread out DD's stuffed animals on the bed like they were having a party on 2 mornings. For some reason, we kept getting more and more bottles of shampoo and conditioner and more bars of soap than we needed.
We loved being in Rapa Nui - very convenient for getting to the TTC, which we used more that the resort line. It was also VERY quiet - could hardly hear anyone in the halls or outside. Plus, we were 3rd floor, so I was very happy to not have anyone above us. We weren't at the resort much, since this was our first family trip to Disney, we really maximized our time in the parks. But the pools were fantastic (DD was in heaven!) and the grounds were so beautiful.
Watched Wishes from the beach 2 nights (one night in the park), enjoyed some Pina Colavas and Bahama Mamas, even a margarita from Tambu lounge one night. Dinner at Kona Cafe one night was delicious and the waitress was fantastic - even brought my daughter an extra dessert (she first said she didn't want dessert, so we chose the fruit to bring back to the room, but then she saw the ice cream sundae and decided she did want dessert after all - I guess when you're 4 1/2, you're entitled to change your mind).
Captain Cooks was pretty good, too, but the one evening DD wanted a pizza to eat in the room with Grandma while DH and I went out, they were down to one oven so it took FOREVER.
I unfortunately never got a Lapu Lapu or a Dole Whip, but hey - they're on the top of my list for whenever we go back.
Oh - a few other little things. Had some monorail issues throughout the stay, but nothing horrible. Seems like there are definitely some bugs to be worked out, though! And, one evening on the beach, we daughter went up to a palm tree and grabbed it with both hands - and walked away all scraped up and with splinters in every finger!! We had no idea you can't touch a palm tree trunk! She was pretty upset, DH ran around trying to find tweezers or a straight pin, but she wouldn't even let him near her to try to take them out. We almost ended up taking a bus to the Orlando urgent care center (we were astounded that the only first aid is available in the parks!) but luckily, after a good night's sleep, they didn't seem to be bothering her. And the two big ones worked their way out after a big day of swimming softened up her skin. She still has a bunch of little ones, but I don't think they're anything to worry about.
So - all in all, a fantastic stay at the Poly. We got a TON done in all of the parks and I have over 1300 photos to go through, plus the PhotoPass ones to look at.
Thanks to everyone here for tips, suggestions, etc - it was all very helpful!!!