Good thread!
We just got back from a trip to
Disneyland trip where we stayed at the Quality Inn and Suites for 6-nights. The trip before that, 2-years ago, we stayed at Stovall's Inn (6-nights, also). The following is our experience and perspective on the differences:
I don't remember exactly, but we only paid about $10 more per night at Stovall's. We went with QI&S this time because it was the cheapest.
QI&S
is a little closer to the park, but, honestly, it felt like the same distance. This may have been partly because they're not really THAT much different. More than that though, when going to Stovall's, you get to walk through DTD, GCH and then walk along a quiet, winding, tree-lined street. So Stovall's has a significantly nicer walk from start to finish which "eases" you out of the Disney experience much better. Also, if you don't want to walk, you can take the bus from Stovall's. No busses go to or from QI&S.
When we stayed at Stovall's, we had a pretty large room with 2-queen sized beds. QI&S had one double sized bed and a twin sized sofa sleeper. The Sofa sleeper was SOOO uncomfortable we took the mattress off the couch and slept with the springy, extremely uncofortable mattress on the floor. Not a good experience. I ended up using pillows and cushions on the floor to sleep on instead of the mattress.
The room at QI&S seemed clean enough, but the bathtub had some damage to it that made me hesitate using it. I'm sure all tubs aren't damaged, though.
The only thing I didn't like about Stovall's was that the rooms were very dark. Dark furniture, beds, walls. QI&S was much more bright and cheery and had nice landscaping. It also had friendly staff.
Next time, we're just going to be sure we have enough money to stay at the DLH.