We have two favorite resorts. And with all those built since and in between, they are still our favorites:
BWV - looked at the end of 1999 and closed in the beginning of 2000. Of course it was the only one available as BC wasn't offered yet and we didn't want OKW. (I don't remember if it was sold out as we weren't interested in it - not that we don't love OKW too
Reasons:
Location, location and location being in between two parks is awesome!
Pool slide which we loved more as the kids got bigger

LOVE JELLYROLLS!
ESPN - DH & DS are sports fans
Easy enjoyable dining options
Strolling entertainment each night
Love the light airy feel of the rooms
Love the size of whirlpool tub in the one bedrooms and up
Etc, Etc, Etc
Animal Kingdom Villa's
Reasons:
The animals!
The atmosphere
The gorgeous rooms
The close proximity to AKP
Sanaa/Jiko/Boma
And most definitely, the lobby store in the lodge. To me, best store on property....but that's just me....
While it's got it's downside, being so far from everything, that's also something I find appealing sometimes. Such as when I go with the girls or on a solo trip. The peace and quite and distant from all the rest is very relaxing.
I wish they had an on-site spa....now that would be a huge plus!