My brother and his girlfriend (college students) stopped there every afternoon when we were there 12/03 (since they're college students, they were on a 'ahem' different eating budget than us - my family would be at Le Cellier, Rose & Crown, or one of the Boardwalk restaurants). The line would be halfway across the bridge (toward France - that would equate to 30-40 people in line) and they'd be like "nope, that's not too long a wait". As we were all driving back home they kept saying how much they'd miss that fish.
So I guess if you asked him - he'd give a rather positive report.
Me, I've not eaten there (yet).