Yacht Club or Cars Suite

Scomadtzoo

Earning My Ears
Joined
Sep 28, 2015
Messages
17
First off there is 9 of us going to Disney the first week of December. There is myself, my mom, my wife, our 2 daughters (both under 3), my wife's friend and her 3 kids (10 D,9 D, and 7 S). My wife was recently laid off from her job, and my wife's friend is a single mother of 3. Financially we can afford a budget friendly trip at a deluxe hotel but obviously now saving money is important as well. So we have two groups paying for their trips My family and my wife's friend family.

So I have officially switched hotels at Disney about 7 times.

We have now booked rooms at AOA, GF, BC, SS, AK, AOA, YC. All about the same dates I have lost Dining Reservations that I now could still be using and been sent like 5 vacation package booklets. So yeah its been fun so far hahahahaha.

But now I am in the biggest conundrum I have had to date. I just recently switched (Yesterday hahahaha) from Nemo at AOA to Yacht Club. It costs only a few 100 more dollars for each group and I though it was well worth it for the convenience of the yacht club to the parks and boardwalk. This will be my third time at Disney and I have only stayed Beach Club so it's also what I am familiar with. Now today I looked and there is now a holiday savings offer at Cars Suites at AOA that will save us about 500 each group.

At this point to be honest I am leaning towards AOA but the familiarity and convenience to the Parks and the Boardwalk, coupled with the fact I'm not a huge Cars fan hahahaha is stopping me from pushing that trigger.

I know no one on here can make the choice for me but a little guidance would be so very much appreciated.
 
In your situation saving $500 is important. You can use that money for food and souvenirs. I would definitely go with 2 AoA suites.
 
Ok well it's all a mute point now because the rooms no longer seem available but if something happens to pop up down the road here I am still interested on your thoughts.
 
Money matters.

Honest disclosure: I've never stayed at AoA - we visited the hotel when it was brand new and thought the theming was fun, but the resort itself is ENORMOUS and made me think of a (very colorful) warehouse. There, you've only got a quick service restaurant, so your options are more limited than at a deluxe (especially Yacht or Beach Club, where you have those resorts + Boardwalk + EPCOT all in easy reach). I've also heard that the AoA rooms are rather uncomfortable - thin walls, scratchy bedding... it's just not for me.

But. Money matters. I think this is one where you should talk to the other adults involved - ask if they'd rather splurge on the room/location or save that to use for a character meal or souvenirs or simply money in the bank.

Either way, you'll be at Disney World, so I don't know if there's a WRONG answer... just a matter of which is more right for your group at this particular time. :)
 
My family is going in December as well and we specifically chose the BC for the convenience of getting to EP and HS during a more crowded time. FYI, YC is currently being refurbished so you may have some minor construction interruptions. I also was considering switching from BC to YC for a few hundred less. We decided to stay put over the savings.

We have stayed in the Cars Duites before and the kids loved it!! They fought over the Mater bed at night. I'm not sure I would want to have to take a bus everywhere though. I saw some crazy long lines for the buses last week for AOA and Pop.

I've done several budget conscious trips at the EP resorts! So it can be done, but we don't eat a lot or buy many souvenirs.
 
This is almost exactly why I didn't hit the change button..... While I have heard ok things about the buses it worries me that the convenience factor of literally being able to walk almost anywhere and back will make it not as enjoyable. And with two kids under 3 it needs to be as convenient as possible. I just wish I never would have cancelled my original booking we had BC Lagoon View for a little over 400 a night on a pin code.
 
You may want to consider the Swan/Dolphin. Typically for that time of year you will see rates around $245 that would put you all in at around $300 which would include taxes and fees. Same area, same basic level of service, just not as "Disney" themed. The Swan was just completely renovated.
 
Would the waldorf be a good compromise. How about a group meeting and see. I would maybe even wait until you everything picks up. Sorry to hear about being laid off that must have been awful. I maybe even wait a year to see how everything is. You will be thinking about money all the way during a trip and thats not good. Maybe waiting until everything picks up might be an idea
 
You may want to consider the Swan/Dolphin. Typically for that time of year you will see rates around $245 that would put you all in at around $300 which would include taxes and fees. Same area, same basic level of service, just not as "Disney" themed. The Swan was just completely renovated.

I second this. Swan/Dolphin (our preference being the Swan) is our go-to when we've missed the discounts at the other EP resorts. If you go directly to the Swan/Dolphin website , you will see the best pricing. If you become a SPG member (Starwood Preferred Guest), you can typically get even better discounts. Just keep in mind, there is no ME, so you would have to arrange your own transportation to and from the airport. You won't get MagicBands, but you can make your FP+ at 60 days prior.

I personally can't recommend the Waldorf. The rooms are lovely, but it is a convention resort with a convention feel and the transportation is worse than AoA's. The buses come very infrequently.
 
In your situation i would probably aim for two standard rooms in either the BWI, BC, or YC and request joining rooms. No shame in downgrading to two moderate rooms in CBR or POR if you wanna save even more money (those two resorts have rooms with a 5th murphy bed). I feel the convenience of having the Magic Bands and the FP+ reservations and the Disney buses would be worth it, imo.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom