I live in Naperville, been here almost 19 years...my DD attends college in Sarasota. She has no plans on returning back home if she can help it. I agree w/her.
To be fair, however......if weather is NOT a top priority for you, and you can afford to travel to WDW from here, then it isn't too bad. If you want, pm me about the company/area...I'll help you out with any questions you may have.
Congrats on 2 job offers! You say the salaries are fairly equal, I am thinkng you would be living larger on that in Orlando then Naperville...just in housing cost alone. Do you have kids?
one big thing to keep in mind is, IF you decided to leave the job in either place, which area offers you a btter chance of finding a new job fairly quickly? Which area is more marketable for your career? Also, look into renting in either place at first, I think it can take 1-2 years to truly get comfortable w/your surroundings to decide wher to buy.
ETA: Don't want to scare you off, Naperville is fine , especially if moving to the MidWest. DD will go wherever a career is...but she has grown very fond of the tropical living and nature in Sarasota. I am dying ot know what field you are in that offers similar salry in both Naperville an Orlando. Also, I tend to prefer the west side of Orlando, but ebig in Gainesville, it is hard to not take the Orlando position...unless relo is covered!
Pam