We really enjoyed California Grille last October. Despite other posts to the contrary, it was not very noisy when we were there, although it was filled. We were not right next to a window, but we had a spectacular view of the lagoon and Castle. The sunset was beautiful. Our server was friendly and helpful. We shared a flatbread appetizer with sausage and basil--outstanding. I had a glass of chardonnay, hubby had iced tea. He had a delicious salmon and I had the melt-in-your-mouth free-range chicken. Sooo good. For dessert, we shared the Chocolate Hazelnut Pyramid--can't say enough about how good that was! Our server encouraged us to linger over coffee to see the fireworks--they were fantastic. The restaurant dims the lights and pipes in the music. With a generous tip we spent well under $100.
Although I was not too crazy about anything else at the Contemporary (we stayed at Poly), would definitely do California Grille again.