Most meals at WDW are pretty good. But there are 2 bad experiences I remember quite well from that trip.
Worst experience overall: Rose and Crown- We still laugh today as we recall that night. I swear I thought we were on Candid Camera! Let me start by saying the food was excellent! However, we had a VERY friendly squirrel (we were seated outside) that was consistently trying to get on our table and steal our food. As the meal progressed he sat right by my side and jumped on my shoulder. I screamed and and jumped from the table! We told the server and she says "Oh, that's just Brian!"

Apparently, he hangs out often. He came back a few minutes later and I was done with trying to hide my meal from him. So, we asked to be moved. They kindly moved us and then our other server (she was in training) spilled a tea refill on my friend's lap.

Poor woman, she was so embarrassed she never returned. The other server came by and offered towels then said pick any dessert you want, this has been a horrible night. We had already ordered dessert (
DDP) so she offered my DD a lighted souvenir cup and UK beer mugs for us! We still have them and use them often. We ate our desserts and watched Illuminations laughing about the night. What else could have gone wrong? It was a real time comedy show! We still laugh about Brian the squirrel and it is one of our favorite memories.
WORST FOOD: CRT. Yep, no kidding. We spent 2 dining credits on this meal and it was the worst. We ate lunch there and I am glad we did it but we will not go back. The service was amazing. The princesses did a great job, although one of them missed our table. No biggie! The food? Barely average. There was 1 child and 3 adults in our party and we all had bland food. My daughter and I ordered steak and both came to us well done. Neither of us enjoy well done steak. So, I asked to have them sent back. Upon receiving another well done steak I just decided to eat a little of it, rather than waste more time. Everyone else had eaten there food at this point. As I put a spoon full of mashed potatoes in my mouth I felt something scrape the roof of my mouth. I pulled out a piece of a plastic bag, probably from the mashed potatoes. I called the server back again and showed them the plastic. They were very apologetic and removed the plate. I said we will just have the dessert at this point. We had fast passes to get to and we had been there for hours!!! Dessert was also mediocre IMO. The chef did come to our table to apologize, which I appreciated. He did have my meal credited to my account. The customer service was wonderful, just the food was not good to us! While I am glad we had the experience of eating in the castle, and my daughter loved meeting the princesses, we all agree that we would not eat there again.