Greetings all...
As you can see this is my first post on the DIS boards though I've been a fan of the Disney vision since my first Disney movie many, many years ago. And while I've been a lurker for awhile here, when I saw the topic listing I thought I would finally jump in to the fun!
I'm not sure, though, about staying in the castle overnight. Yeah, when I was younger I thought it would be really cool to stay there, but now that I'm a little older (in body, at least) I think it would be lonely and depressing. To me, the Magic Kingdom is Magically when it is alive, not when it is dark with only sanitation and maintenance crews working. So while staying in the castle during the day would be really, really cool (as has been said), I think after everybody leaves, I would much prefer to be in one of the resorts.
Truthfully, one of the most depressing feelings I ever experienced was when I was walking through a shuttered amusement park or an empty cruise ship.
But the concept of a castle/palace resort area is a great one...it probably has been kicked around a few times at Disney as I'm sure a few guests have put it on their comment cards (at least I did as well as some of our friends...hey, they listened to us about the WL!). It would be quite interesting to see if they could do an entire castle/palace-themed resort (moderate, of course, so families could afford it) where each building was representative of a different country's royal/noble residence.
Could you imagine staying in a Bavarian castle or a Doge's palace? A Scottish Baron's castle or the Taj Mahal (o.k., admittedly the Taj Mahal is technically a memorial/shrine, but it is archetypical)? How about a Shogun's palace or Basque castle? It would be fairly easy to come up with a list of a dozen or so such residences from across the globe! And I think putting it on the North-east side of Bay lake would make it stand out by itself or the southeast corner of the Lake just east of FW.
I wonder if we can start a "If I were going to design a resort" thread or voting poll to see what type of resort would go over with the other DIS members. It would be nice, however, if we could stay away from another beach/caribbean-southwestern/sunset-pastel type resort for awhile; it seems like most of the moderates and DVC villas are already themed that way almost generically...though that's my opinion at least.
My list - 1) Castle resort; 2) Venetian resort (on the water, please); 3) Wonders of the Ancient World resort (Hanging Gardens of Babylon, Lighthouse of Alexandria, etc.); 4) Colonial village; 5) Crystal Palace resort.
...and have a magical day!